PygmalionOfCyprus / cmo-db-requests

Public issue/request tracking for the Command: Modern Operations database
49 stars 17 forks source link

S-125 neva correction #4528

Open TTZ32 opened 4 months ago

TTZ32 commented 4 months ago

DB Selector

DB3K

Affected DBID(s)

Facility 1617

Summary of Changes

Serbian crews have used the S-125 Neva to attack a simulated surface vessel at 11km during the Sablja excercises in Bulgaria.

Serbian S-125 can also use 5V27D missiles as shown below. Also a request to remove the P-19 from the Serbian variant and add the P-18.

Sources

Video is in Serbian and states that the missile can be used to attack both surface and ground targets at a distance of 17km. Obviously the targets would have to be within radar LoS

https://youtu.be/7WdT3jVLYFY?si=sJLXuAJjLpmDRUIx

5V27D source here https://www.mod.gov.rs/eng/10809/lansirna-rampa-i-rakete-neva-za-dan-secanja-10809

PavelNovak79 commented 4 months ago

Regarding missiles soviet export charts give this: 768 5V27U delivered in 1974-78 (note 5V27U is minor upgrade od 5V27, game wise same) 437 5V27D delivered in 1981-87 plus 12 training ones

Regarding radars I think that P-15/P-19 were standard with Yugoslav S-125 units just like with everybody else. I think that P-18 deployment was rather exception than rule and as such it can be done by modification of unit in scenario creation.

Finally yes S-125 can attack ground and surface targets as it has command guided missiles but currently in game it is represented as SARH so it doesn't have that ability in game. Usefulness of this capacity is theoretical anyway.

TTZ32 commented 4 months ago

Regarding missiles soviet export charts give this: 768 5V27U delivered in 1974-78 (note 5V27U is minor upgrade od 5V27, game wise same) 437 5V27D delivered in 1981-87 plus 12 training ones

Regarding radars I think that P-15/P-19 were standard with Yugoslav S-125 units just like with everybody else. I think that P-18 deployment was rather exception than rule and as such it can be done by modification of unit in scenario creation.

Finally yes S-125 can attack ground and surface targets as it has command guided missiles but currently in game it is represented as SARH so it doesn't have that ability in game. Usefulness of this capacity is theoretical anyway.

P-12, P15 and P-18 radars were used by Yugoslavia, not P-19. Besides the fact that we arent talking about yugoslavia, Serbia today uses P-18 radars for its S-125 batteries

PavelNovak79 commented 4 months ago

Thanks for correction regarding P-19. Soviet export charts I have are limited (there are some radars listed like P-14 but there are not P-15/19) - anyway attached it is in djvu format.

USSR air defence equipment export.zip

I see that in database DB505 Serbia has one entry for SA-3 SAM unit with 5V27 and P-19 radar - entry 1617. Also Yugoslav entry 116 has P-19 radar. So if they don't have it these entries should get P-15 radar [Flat Face A]. Also separate radar entries for Yugoslavia 2570 and Serbia 2571 should be changed to P-15 radar.

SA-3c [S-125M] with 5V27D missiles then should be added as new entry. Where Yugoslav entry with starting year 1981 should keep P-15 radar while Serbian entry can have that P-18 radar as game simplification.