search

Qabel / qabel.github.io

:octocat: The Qabel documentation repository. The technical stuff can be found at our github.io page.
https://qabel.github.io
Other
2 stars 10 forks source link

DropURL length should be fixed #151

Open audax opened 8 years ago

audax commented 8 years ago

By allowing the user to chose the length of the DropURL, we reduce the chance for collisions and we have to explain what all that stuff actually means.

Is it really worth it or should we just use a reasonable default value?

roeslpa commented 8 years ago

I am in favor of letting the user decide. Because users who use a mobile device would decide different than users who only use the desktop version. But instead of "less" and "much" I would write "little traffic and low anonymity" and "much traffic and high anonymity" and add a description for interested users below.

hash13 commented 8 years ago

yes a description is imho needed. maybe a ''button" until the user can change to traffic.... 'whats this' or 'more infos'. iam send you @audax a pm with a wording example

roeslpa commented 8 years ago

In my current android version (from last Thursday) the description is actually wrong: questions: "how paranoid are you" and "how much traffic would you accept" -> answer: "less" should mean that many URL bits are used (=> few collisions => few users use one URL => little traffic) but it is implemented the other way around: "less" indicates few bits are used.

jmt85 commented 8 years ago

what is the state of this ticket

roeslpa commented 8 years ago

From my point of view if we fix the length to a certain value we (have to) answer the big question nobody ever answered regarding Qabel Drop: (when) will Qabel Drop scale (on mobile devices)? If anybody can answer this, please set a default value. I belief nobody can answer this question because of the variable setting of mobile devices. Hence I would like to variably find out the answer by observing the behaviour (at least during the beta).