Qucs / qucs

Qucs Project official mirror
http://qucs.sourceforge.net/
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.15k stars 213 forks source link

spice4qucs: DC analysis not found in netlist #564

Closed ldpgh closed 7 years ago

ldpgh commented 8 years ago

Hello, it seems the DC analysis is not exported to Ngspice (no .DC in the netlist seen)

If Qucsator is used saveOp=yes provides all device information as desired.

spice4qucs 0.0.19 @ Win7Pro

ldpgh commented 8 years ago

AC analysis works as expected TRAN analysis works as expected

ra3xdh commented 8 years ago

DC analysis in Qucs is approximate equivalent of SPICE .OP analysis. OP is performed automatically when TRAN or AC is executed and .DC don't require to be explicitly added into the SPICE netlist. Also you can use "Show bias" (press F8 key) to see operation point. SPICE .DC is emulated with Qucs DC+ParSweep. I haven't previously used saveOp option to look at DC bias. I will consider later how to add putting OP into dataset feature.

You may use the following two places for bugtracker for Qucs-S:

  1. The following spice4qucs discussion thread #77
  2. My home repository https://github.com/ra3xdh/qucs You can open issues related to SPICE supports here. Don't use it to report bugs of mainline Qucs!

I think main Qucs repository should not be used for posting issues on spice4qucs (except #77 and #181), because it can lead to mixing up of mainline Qucs and Qucs-S bugs.

ldpgh commented 8 years ago

Regarding 1.

Regarding 2.

Agree with you keeping spice4qucs separated from main-line.

ra3xdh commented 8 years ago

I have enabled issues at my home repository. See https://github.com/ra3xdh/qucs/issues

ra3xdh commented 7 years ago

Transferred to my home repository as related to spice4qucs subsystem only. See https://github.com/ra3xdh/qucs/issues/10 to continue discussion.