Open ngoiyaeric opened 1 month ago
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Test Coverage The test for processing events (lines 106-120) only checks if certain functions are called, but doesn't verify the correctness of their outputs or how they interact. Consider adding more detailed assertions. Incomplete Testing The LandUseAgent test (lines 48-64) only checks if the execute method returns an empty object. This might not be sufficient to ensure the agent's functionality. Consider adding more comprehensive tests for this agent. Mock Implementation The test for handling errors during research (lines 40-49) mocks the global fetch function. This approach might not accurately represent all possible error scenarios. Consider using a more robust mocking strategy or testing actual API calls in a controlled environment. |
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Improve test coverage for LandUseAgent by adding more specific test cases___ **In the LandUseAgent test, consider adding more specific test cases to verify thebehavior of the execute method. The current test only checks if an empty object is returned, which may not be sufficient to ensure the agent is functioning correctly.** [app/agents/Agent.test.tsx [59-63]](https://github.com/QueueLab/mapgpt/pull/73/files#diff-9f9048ad51fd052842a529d5bd1212b1bda6e9b8a35d9669ee65533cacb34ea9R59-R63) ```diff -it('should execute and return an empty object', async () => { +it('should execute and return the expected result', async () => { + const mockResult = { landUseData: 'some data' }; + jest.spyOn(landUseAgent, 'execute').mockResolvedValue(mockResult); const result = await landUseAgent.execute(); - expect(result).toEqual({}); + expect(result).toEqual(mockResult); + expect(uiStream.append).toHaveBeenCalled(); }); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion enhances test coverage by verifying the behavior of the execute method with specific expected results, improving the reliability of the test. | 8 |
Enhance test assertions by verifying specific function call arguments___ **Consider using more specific assertions in the test cases. Instead of just checkingif certain functions were called, assert on the specific arguments passed to these functions. This will make the tests more robust and catch potential issues with the data being passed.** [app/actions.test.tsx [117-119]](https://github.com/QueueLab/mapgpt/pull/73/files#diff-fa2ec543ec1f4f40fd9924314de4a32cbdc6f88d8f805939c0b0d290ea1eb326R117-R119) ```diff -expect(taskManager).toHaveBeenCalled() -expect(researcher).toHaveBeenCalled() -expect(querySuggestor).toHaveBeenCalled() +expect(taskManager).toHaveBeenCalledWith(expect.any(Object)) +expect(researcher).toHaveBeenCalledWith(expect.any(Object)) +expect(querySuggestor).toHaveBeenCalledWith(expect.any(Object)) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves the robustness of the tests by ensuring that the functions are called with the correct arguments, which can help catch potential issues with data being passed. | 7 | |
Verify API call parameters in the search tool test to ensure correct data transmission___ **In the successful search test, consider adding assertions to verify that the fetchfunction was called with the correct parameters. This will ensure that the search tool is sending the correct data to the API.** [lib/agents/tools/search.test.tsx [50-54]](https://github.com/QueueLab/mapgpt/pull/73/files#diff-1bbbd960d3a03540d69992f30d4469d2de4505244cba389e3da5d9e9687cad00R50-R54) ```diff const tool = searchTool({ uiStream, fullResponse }); const result = await tool.execute({ query, max_results, search_depth }); expect(result).toEqual(searchResult); expect(uiStream.append).toHaveBeenCalledWith( Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: By adding assertions to check the parameters of the fetch function, this suggestion ensures that the search tool is correctly interacting with the API, enhancing test accuracy. | 7 | |
Enhance error handling test by using and asserting on a specific error message___ **In the error handling test, consider using a more specific error message andasserting on it. This will ensure that the error handling is working as expected and that the correct error message is being displayed.** [lib/agents/researcher.test.tsx [41-49]](https://github.com/QueueLab/mapgpt/pull/73/files#diff-c2fe5e560dbaefc17eaae3a95d811070c44ecb6fca8a706d0a6245d77de3bffbR41-R49) ```diff +const errorMessage = 'Network error during research'; jest.spyOn(global, 'fetch').mockImplementation(() => - Promise.reject(new Error('Network error')) + Promise.reject(new Error(errorMessage)) ); const result = await researcher(uiStreamMock, streamTextMock, messagesMock); -expect(result.fullResponse).toContain('Error occurred while executing the tool'); +expect(result.fullResponse).toContain(errorMessage); expect(result.hasError).toBe(true); +expect(uiStreamMock.update).toHaveBeenCalledWith(expect.stringContaining(errorMessage)); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion strengthens the error handling test by ensuring that specific error messages are correctly handled and displayed, which can help in diagnosing issues. | 6 |
๐ก Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
User description
Add test scripts to ensure all tool integrations are working correctly, the chat input works, and streams throughout the system.
Unit Tests for
submit
function:app/actions.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like user input, skip action, etc.getMutableAIState
,createStreamableUI
, etc.Test Scripts for
InquiryAgent
andLandUseAgent
:app/agents/Agent.test.tsx
to test theexecute
method for both classes.getModel
,streamObject
, etc.Test Scripts for
AgentCoordinator
:app/agents/cordinator.test.tsx
to test theexecuteWorkflow
method.upstash
,AgentFactory
, etc.Test Scripts for
searchTool
:lib/agents/tools/search.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like successful search, error handling, etc.tavilySearch
,exaSearch
, etc.Test Scripts for
videoSearchTool
:lib/agents/tools/video-search.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like successful search, error handling, etc.fetch
, etc.Test Scripts for
researcher
:lib/agents/researcher.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like successful research, error handling, etc.createStreamableUI
,createStreamableValue
, etc.Test Scripts for
locationTool
:lib/agents/tools/location.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like successful location intelligence, error handling, etc.createStreamableValue
, etc.Unit Tests for
Mapbox
component:components/map/mapbox-map.test.tsx
to test different scenarios like successful map rendering, error handling, etc.mapbox-gl
, etc.Add test script to
package.json
:For more details, open the Copilot Workspace session.
PR Type
Tests
Description
submit
function, covering scenarios like user input and skip action.InquiryAgent
,LandUseAgent
, andAgentCoordinator
, focusing on execution methods.searchTool
,videoSearchTool
, andlocationTool
, verifying successful operations and error management.package.json
to include necessary dependencies and scripts.Changes walkthrough ๐
8 files
actions.test.tsx
Add unit tests for `submit` function
app/actions.test.tsx
submit
function.getMutableAIState
andcreateStreamableUI
.Agent.test.tsx
Add tests for InquiryAgent and LandUseAgent
app/agents/Agent.test.tsx
InquiryAgent
andLandUseAgent
.getModel
andstreamObject
.cordinator.test.tsx
Add tests for AgentCoordinator execution workflow
app/agents/cordinator.test.tsx
AgentCoordinator
.AgentFactory
andupstash
.executeWorkflow
method.mapbox-map.test.tsx
Add tests for Mapbox component rendering
components/map/mapbox-map.test.tsx
Mapbox
component.mapbox-gl
library.researcher.test.tsx
Add tests for researcher function
lib/agents/researcher.test.tsx
researcher
function.createStreamableUI
.location.test.tsx
Add tests for locationTool execution
lib/agents/tools/location.test.tsx
locationTool
.createStreamableValue
.search.test.tsx
Add tests for searchTool functionality
lib/agents/tools/search.test.tsx
searchTool
.createStreamableUI
.video-search.test.tsx
Add tests for videoSearchTool functionality
lib/agents/tools/video-search.test.tsx
videoSearchTool
.createStreamableUI
.1 files
package.json
Update package.json for Jest integration
package.json
jest
andts-jest
to devDependencies.test
script to run Jest.