RAP-group / guide_to_open_science

A guide to open science and reproducibility for students, advisors, and early career researchers
https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/spz4w
0 stars 0 forks source link

R2: positionality statements, application in linguistics #26

Open jvcasillas opened 1 month ago

jvcasillas commented 1 month ago
  • “Moreover, Bucholtz et al. (2023) note that considering a researcher’s positionality may be especially important in linguistics, “[...] which relies on racially minoritized communities as sources of data yet lack adequate (if any) representation of those communities among faculty researchers” (p. 2).” --> Does this quote really apply to linguistics in general? I can see how it is very relevant for certain areas of linguistics, but there is much linguistic research on major languages, where this point does not seem to apply. Please rephrase / explain.

TODO

RobertEspo commented 3 days ago

If more hedging is desired:

“Moreover, Bucholtz et al. (2023) note that considering a researcher’s positionality may be especially important in linguistic research on certain language communities, such as indigenous communities, “[...] which relies on racially minoritized communities as sources of data yet lack adequate (if any) representation of those communities among faculty researchers” (p. 2).”

jvcasillas commented 15 hours ago

I say we go with @RobertEspo suggestion for now and see how they respond.