Create unified ADRG standard for R submissions

RConsortium / submissions-wg

R Submissions Working Group

https://rconsortium.github.io/submissions-wg

49 stars 14 forks source link

Create unified ADRG standard for R submissions #112

Open nanxstats opened 6 months ago

nanxstats commented 6 months ago

I propose we work together to create a common, unified ADRG content standard and templates for R submissions. This could help simplify work for everyone:

Sponsors would have guidance on how R-specific sections in ADRG should be constructed and what to include. Searching "ADRG" on the submission WG website shows 17 results from past meetings - there are surely some confusions out there.
Reviewers would have clear expectations for the R submission ADRG generated across sponsors, and with a level of consistency, they can standardize their review workflow and save time.

cc @lengning @joseph-rickert

SHAESEN2 commented 6 months ago

Please include me in the future working group.

joseph-rickert commented 6 months ago

The following is a relevant email from Chris Price Hi Joe, All

The ADRG template, referenced in the FDA TCG, is a PHUSE product and we have a process for updating these so that they can continue to be referenced. The team has already started work on including content for open source submissions and would value input from R Consortium Working Groups and members into any necessary updates/enhancements. R Consortium may find more value in contributing to the PHUSE effort rather than duplicating effort on a stand-alone R Consortium template.

Kind regards

Chris

bms63 commented 5 months ago

This was a nice scrapping code from Pilot 4 for getting all package versions and description from renv

https://github.com/RConsortium/submissions-pilot4-webR/blob/7287ced13bf660b74f7e4fb283522ca123907ad6/adrg/_adrg.qmd#L369

nanxstats commented 2 months ago

Sam Parmar kindly shared some (WIP) Quarto templates in the working group meeting today: https://github.com/parmsam/quarto-adrg

nanxstats commented 1 month ago

Looks like an "open source metadata documentation" working group has been formed: https://phuse-org.github.io/OSDocuMeta/

bms63 commented 1 month ago

I think that is the one @laxamanaj (from Pilot 3) is involved with

laxamanaj commented 1 month ago

Hi, @all.

Yes, a PHUSE WG has been formed to work on this, but we definitely welcome input from everyone involved in these R Consortium R Submissions WG Pilots as we've now delivered ADRGs in the last 3 Pilots. Currently, I am co-leading this effort with https://github.com/Lovemore-Gakava . We are brainstorming gradual steps to begin templatizing the ADRG for Open-source submissions and will seek your input in the near future.