RDFBones / RDFBones-O

An RDF ontology for research data from physical anthropology and related fields of expertise.
4 stars 1 forks source link

phaleron-si: Erroneous hierarchy and definitions with ROIs 'Entire set of ribs' #193

Closed cuboideum closed 11 months ago

cuboideum commented 11 months ago

Problem Statement

Class Hierarchy

Class 'Entire set of all ribs' (phaleron-si:EntireSetOfAllRightRibs) is a subclass of 'Anatomical region of interest' and currently defined as follows:

An anatomical region of interest describing the entire set of all ribs in a skeleton.

It has two subclasses:

This contradicts the definition of 'Entire set of all ribs' as the subclasses reference subsets of the superclass.

Class Definitions

The definition of 'Entire set of all left ribs' is as follows:

An anatomical region of interest describing a left rib.

The definition of 'Entire set of all right ribs' is as follows:

An anatomical region of interest describing a right rib.

Both definitions contradict the class labels that indicate sets of multiple ribs.

Required Action

The following changes are necessary:

cuboideum commented 11 months ago

Fixed with pull request https://github.com/RDFBones/Phaleron-SkeletalInventory/pull/28.