Check relation to Stodden’s work

korenmiklos commented 2 years ago

http://stodden.net/papers/Legal-STODDEN2009.pdf

korenmiklos commented 2 years ago

https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/pdf/10.1098/rsta.2020.0069

@csokaimola pls check our standard against these rules and the "Reproduction Package"

korenmiklos commented 2 years ago

https://social-science-data-editors.github.io/guidance/Licensing_guidance.html

csokaimola commented 2 years ago

@korenmiklos I checked the Model Policy/Mapping, E column "Stodden".

I added some references to guidelines, see in yellow, eg. Rule 5&7b:G1 (G1 says: "all artifacts, such as code and data, they used as part of their computational experiments are available" I think the mentioned "programs" and "code in 5&7b belong to"all artifacts" of G1)
and also added if something was mentioned in the "Reproduction Package" (eg. Rule 13a: a README file is also mentioned in the "Reproduction Package").

Another comment: the following phrase appears 4 times: ", to the extent allowed by other agreements and the law." I am not sure it is necessary. I think it could be erased, or put in footnote once.

korenmiklos commented 2 years ago

3 principles -> 12 guidelines -> reproduction package template

REStud / guidance

Check relation to Stodden’s work #27