Compare to Joan's checklist

[korenmiklos]

https://static.primary.prod.gcms.the-infra.com/static/site/ej/document/Checklist_for_authors_July2020.pdf?node=d63a8d83ba1a1421c6f1&version=263849:ae02e800bfdafd0dbf0f

[korenmiklos]

https://github.com/REStud/guidance/blob/main/RRS/Reproducible-Research-Standard-1.0.md

[korenmiklos]

Common

• 13b
• 13c
• 12b
• 12c
• 11e
• 11g
• 5
• 3
• 2a
• 4a
• 8a
• 8c
• 1

Extra

• description of data cleaning
• expected runtime
• synthetic data
• IRB approval

Missing

• 8b

[csokaimola]

Comments:

• What is the difference between in 8b and 8c "survey collection mechanisms" and "details on subject selection"?
• I think all points in "Extra" are important (except maybe IRB, but I am not too familiar with these experiment processes, so I might be wrong) and they were listed in DAP of a lot of TOP5 Journals (see comparison in DAP matrix,Sheet1).