RUB-EP1 / international-k-matrix-day

Educational materials for the K-matrix formalism in the field of hadron physics
https://rub-ep1.github.io/international-k-matrix-day
MIT License
5 stars 1 forks source link

Corrections to the material #16

Open mmikhasenko opened 1 month ago

mmikhasenko commented 1 month ago
mmikhasenko commented 1 month ago

the 3d plots, it might be helpful to indicate where one can pass, where not

where_one_can_gp

e.g. by the color of the line

mmikhasenko commented 1 month ago

as a minor improvement of the plot

you can color the line segment of the same color that has to be equal to each other. +i0 solid -i0 dashed image

Zeyna777 commented 1 month ago

Hi Misha, thank you for the feedback! Will update it asap. I have some questions (just for clarfication):

Question 1: „The expression for rho does not have discontinuity on right“

I know that the branch cut of a complex squareroot goes to the left (from bp to -inf.). I just thought the most common choice in particle physics would be to the right. But technically you could rotate it in an abitrary direction in the complex plane.

Question 2 (dumb I know but just out of curiosity):

“Im CM = rho, other way around“

How this changes the logical statment? If CM=-i rho then i Cm= rho. Maybe I am thinking the wrong way.

mmikhasenko commented 1 month ago

Q1: the mathematical sqrt sign is well defined using Arg function in the range -pi, pi. I'm not aware of any programming language, implementation that would mean anything different for sqrt.

See the principal sqrt in https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_root

The principal square root function is thus defined using the non-positive real axis as a branch cut.

Q2: neither is true:

CM != irho, rho != -iCM

However, Im CM = rho, and importantly only above the threshold.

The functions differ by their real parts everywhere except a few points, and by their imaginary part below the threshold.