search

RWS / dxa-web-application-java

SDL Digital Experience Accelerator Java Spring MVC web application
25 stars 37 forks source link

Version 2.1.1 Does not compile #118

Closed bimalsubedi closed 5 years ago

bimalsubedi commented 5 years ago

Hello, We are using the dxa version of 2.1.1 that was uploaded to maven repository in March in our web application however it seems that there is dependency problem with the library udp-api-broker. I am getting the following error Could not resolve dependencies for project Failed to collect dependencies at com.sdl.dxa:dxa-tridion-provider:jar:2.1.1 -> com.sdl.dxa:dxa-tridion-common:jar:2.1.1 -> com.sdl.delivery:udp-api-broker:jar:(,11.0.1): No versions available for com.sdl.delivery:udp-api-broker:jar:(,11.0.1) within specified range -> [Help 1] I also cloned the source code of release/2.1.1 and it also gives the same error. Is there any prevision to resolve this error?

rpannekoek commented 5 years ago

There appears to be a mistake here; we did not release DXA 2.1 Java at all. We will do a DXA Model Service 2.1.1 hotfix release (DXA 2.1 .NET release does contain the DXA Model Service, which is implemented in Java), but the other DXA Java artifacts should not have been released to Maven Central.

bimalsubedi commented 5 years ago

So is it possible to remove that version from maven repository and leave only the stable version? This brings us a lot of confusion and now we don't know which is the latest stable version of DXA that we can use. Would appreciate if you could provide me with that information.

rpannekoek commented 5 years ago

Yes, we will work on cleaning this up to avoid the confusion. For clarity: for DXA Java, version 2.0 is the latest release (you can use the release/2.0 branch to obtain the sources). Note that since the 2.0 release, several hotfix releases have been done (focused at the DXA Model Service), so you will find 2.0.2 artifact versions. The release/2.0 branch includes those hotfixes; you can use the DXA_2.0_Release tag if you want to get the sources of DXA 2.0.0 (i.e. excluding hotfixes).

fdvalencia commented 5 years ago

Hi Rick I have tried to use version 2.0.2 version but its missing a dependency:

dxa-module-core 2.0.2

its not uploaded to the mvn repository

rpannekoek commented 5 years ago

This is very unfortunate... We recently did a DXA 2.0.2 Model Service hotfix release, but a blocking issue has been found after release, which required us to release 2.0.3 versions of the DXA framework. Indeed, not all 2.0.2 artifacts were published yet; we will work on publishing all 2.0.2 artifacts to make things a bit less confusing. But note that you should not use the 2.0.2 artifacts, but use the 2.0.3 ones instead. By now, the release/2.0 branch also references these 2.0.3 versions.

rpannekoek commented 5 years ago

Internal Issue ID for cleaning up the confusion around DXA 2.1 release: TSI-3900

rpannekoek commented 5 years ago

Unfortunately, it is not possible to unpublish the DXA 2.1.1 artifacts from Maven Central, however we have cleaned up GitHub, so there are no references to DXA 2.1.x artifacts anymore. In particular:

I hope this is sufficient to avoid confusion.

bimalsubedi commented 5 years ago

Thank you Rick, This makes thing a bit more clear.