RamblingCookieMonster / PSDepend

PowerShell Dependency Handler
MIT License
283 stars 76 forks source link

Cannot reference specific version of prerelease #132

Open avalery opened 3 years ago

avalery commented 3 years ago

Let's stay I published a module named MyModule with a prerelease version 1.2.3-alpha, and tried to use it as a dependency using this configuration:

@{
    'MyModule' = @{
        Name = 'MyModule'
        Version = '1.2.3-alpha'
        Parameters = @{
            AllowPrerelease = $true
        }
    }
}

If I call Invoke-PSDepend "requirements.psd1" -Install -Force -Import to download them and import them automatically, I got an error when PSDepend triggers Import-Module, because it gives "1.2.3-alpha" and Import-Module call only accept "1.2.3".

Isn't possible in PSDepend to adapt the code: if the module is a prerelease, trigger Import-Module with the version number without the prerelease "tag"?

avalery commented 2 years ago

Any news about this issue?

fourpastmidnight commented 1 year ago

I'm looking for this, too. It looks like this has become abandonware. 😢 I have a PR open on another of his modules, BuildHelpers, but crickets.

fourpastmidnight commented 1 year ago

OK, I tried this using a different configuration. In my case, I was trying to get the updated PowerShellGet module, now called PSResourceGet. Here's the configuration I used:

@{
    PSResourceGet = @{
        Name = 'Microsoft.PowerShell.PSReourceGet'
        DependencyType = 'PSGalleryModule'
        Version = 'latest'
        Parameters = @{
            AllowPrerelease = $true
        }
    }
}

However, it looked like the first time around, all that happened was that the module was "installed" to my specified target path. A subsequent run of PSDepend resulted in an error:

Checking for and installing the latest versions of the build system dependencies...
WARNING: Access to the path 'D:\src\git\MyProject\build\deps\Microsoft.PowerShell.PSResourceGet\0.5.24' is denied.
Save-Package: Unable to save the module 'Microsoft.PowerShell.PSResourceGet'.
Import-Module: C:\Users\me\Documents\PowerShell\Modules\PSDepend\0.3.8\Private\Import-PSDependModule.ps1:21
Line |
  21 |              Import-Module @importParams
     |              ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
     | The specified module 'D:\src\git\MyProject\build\deps\Microsoft.PowerShell.PSResourceGet' was not loaded because no valid module
     | file was found in any module directory.

It seems the problem here, is that the Version that is specified in the PSDepend configuration is not updated properly when subsequently passed to Import-Module since the RequiredVersion parameter is of type System.Version, which is a Microsoft-proprietary version number format. PowerShell (at the time this is currently written) really doesn't understand the notion of "pre-release" versions. If you look in the module folder hierarchy, e.g. C:\Users\<you>\Documents\PowerShell\Modules, using PSResourceGet as an example module that only has a pre-release version published:

C:\Users\<you>\Documents\PowerShell\Modules
  └─ Microsoft.PowerShell.PSResourceGet
       └─ 0.5.24
            └─ <other files>

But the real version of this module is 0.5.24-beta24. The way a "pre-release" version of a module is specified is by a metadata field in the module's PSD1 manifest. So, when importing a pre-release module, the pre-release tag must be stripped from the version string.

I'm looking to create a PR for this issue. When I've done so, if @RamblingCookieMonster does not merge this in, you can always clone from my branch. I do this with BuildHelpers currently, as I have an open PR on this module, too, where I added some functionality. Instead of using the PowerShellGet version, I clone my git repo and checkout the branch containing my feature. Just be aware that when using git dependencies, PSDepend can't do an "import" on them because not all git dependencies are PowerShell modules. Too bad there isn't a way to "enable" importing a PowerShell module based on a cloned Git repo....sounds like a custom provider for PSDepend to me! 😉

fourpastmidnight commented 1 year ago

@avalery In lieu of cloning my git repo, this really is a single-line change. You could just update your copy of the module for now, according to the diff shown in my PR to resolve your issue. Hope that helps!