Open dwz92 opened 8 months ago
R is not properly cited
No indication of a class paper
LLM usage is documented
Title is not informative enough to give a suggestion of the story
Author, date, and repo is not clearly indicated in the script
Abstract not included
The introduction gives a good understanding of the story
No Estimand
No explanation of data, lack of graphs and tables
No clear section of measurement, need to resolve the merge conflict in the paper
Some explanation of results, but no clear indication of the result
Not enough discussion
Not all figures and tables are labeled
Lots of code errors, merge conflicts not resolved, and some text explanations but unclear indications.
As mentioned previously, too many code errors and merge conflicts to indicate proper graphs and tables.
No references
More than 2 commits and a meaningful commit message
No sketches
No simulation
No test
Clear Readme
R citation:
R is not properly cited
Class paper:
No indication of a class paper
LLM Usage:
LLM usage is documented
Title:
Title is not informative enough to give a suggestion of the story
Author/s, date, and repo
Author, date, and repo is not clearly indicated in the script
Abstract
Abstract not included
Introduction
The introduction gives a good understanding of the story
Estimand
No Estimand
Data
No explanation of data, lack of graphs and tables
Measurement
No clear section of measurement, need to resolve the merge conflict in the paper
Results
Some explanation of results, but no clear indication of the result
Discussion
Not enough discussion
Cross-refernces
Not all figures and tables are labeled
Prose
Lots of code errors, merge conflicts not resolved, and some text explanations but unclear indications.
Graphs/Tables
As mentioned previously, too many code errors and merge conflicts to indicate proper graphs and tables.
References
No references
Commits
More than 2 commits and a meaningful commit message
Sketches
No sketches
Simulation
No simulation
Test
No test
Reproducibility
Clear Readme