ReScience / ReScience-article-2

Repository for the upcoming ReScience article
6 stars 14 forks source link

Anonymization of young researchers #32

Closed apdavison closed 7 years ago

apdavison commented 7 years ago

The text currently says:

"Until we implement a certified anonymized submission process, this strong bias will most likely remain."

But wouldn't we need both anonymous submission and anonymous publication (since otherwise retaliation could happen post-publication), and wouldn't the latter remove much of the incentive of publishing in the first place?

rougier commented 7 years ago

You're right, maybe this part is not clear enough. Ideally, we would like to have a system for anonymous submission/publication but with a way for anonymous author to prove they have published in ReScience (or that they have published this specific article). But we have no such solution yet.