Closed khinsen closed 6 years ago
of course I realize now that I am aware of it via your retweet, irony :-)
@pdebuyl Thanks for the pointer! As you may have guessed, I had actually written the draft before seeing R.D. Peng's tweet.
I have added a somewhat vague reference at the end of the draft, but perhaps someone with a better knowledge of NAS activities in this domain could improve on it.
Thanks @khinsen. Overall I think the letter may be too centered on the journal itself instead of being more broadly centred on sustainable computational science. I'm not sure if I'm clear and I'm not sure either what to change... I've added small suggestions.
I have added a reference to sustainability in two places - this is indeed important, given that it's the first word of the title!
Marcia McNutt and I served on a panel on reproducibility for an event that she organized the last two years. I could also approach her if other venues into PNAS don't pan out.
What do we do know ? @karthik or @ctb send the letter + raft or is it better if it is @khinsen or me ?
Hi folks, on it - I am happy to communicate the letter and draft. Only change I would suggest is "Dear PNAS editorial board". Also, shall we have @khinsen "sign" it at the bottom, e.g.
Signed, Konrad Hinsen, for the authors
?
See https://github.com/khinsen/ReScience-article-2/pull/2 for changes.
And the master branch draft.pdf is the right draft to send along?
Yes, I think the current master draft is the right one. Alternatively, can also use the arXiv one.
@khinsen do you take care of making the submission to PNAS?
I thought @ctb was doing it?
Oh, you're right. @ctb, can you send the letter+draft next week ?
yep.
@ctb Did you send the letter?
Monday.
Do you mean you sent it last Monday or you'll do it today?
@ctb Any update ?
@ctb I am also a bit at a loss as to the meaning of "Monday"!
Hi, sorry for the confusion(s). It's been sent to Rich and I'll let you know when I hear back!
best, --titus
@ctb Great, thanks a lot!
It might be interesting to mention the fact that
seen here via R. D. Peng