search

ReScience / ten-years

Ten Years Reproducibility Challenge
BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
62 stars 5 forks source link

Pre-submission check #11

Closed bpbond closed 4 years ago

bpbond commented 4 years ago

For paper 33 I have re-run the code and drafted a reproducibility report. Would someone mind taking a look? Anything major missing from your point of view? This was a fairly simple reproducibility challenge, and it actually worked 🎉 , so that kind of limits the length/detail.

Thank you!

Paper 33 Reproducibility Report-12 Years Later….pdf

P.S. repository is here.

rougier commented 4 years ago

Results are impressive actually, only a tiny difference. Any idea where it comes from ? For the actual article, you're free to extend your report and anlysis. I think the conclusion is really interesting (R core vs tidyverse) and could be extended a bit (because this is precisely the things we want to know).

For the article, you can also have a look at current submissions to check if you forgot something.

bpbond commented 4 years ago

Thanks for the deadline extension. Submitted. I didn't use the ReScience template but happy to do that down the road.