Declaration of participation

[rougier]

This thread collects declaration of participation to the Ten Years Reproducibility Challenge. You can add your own declaration by adding the article your target with possibly a link to an open access version of the PDF.

Declared number of participants: 35 Number of targeted papers: 43 Oldest targeted paper: 28 years old (@MikeSilberbauer)

[khinsen]

OK everyone, in particular @broukema, @bpbond, @pbnjay, @BrunoLevy, @a-kharechko : one more deadline extension until Monday, May 4th, any time zone of this planet (which effectively makes it May 5th 11:00 UTC if I understood time zones correctly).

[pbnjay]

Sorry that doesn't help me much at all. Thursday or Friday would have been doable, but it's the weekend and I have obligations and a family.

[rougier]

I guess we can be pretty flexible and we won't reject your submission if you submit by next week-end (one week extra for all of you).

[broukema]

Just a followup to Konrad's time zone point: in principle the 4 May deadline would have been12:00 UTC, 5 May, which is for the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Howland_and_Baker_islands, which satisfies the IEEE 802.16 AOE standard, where AOE = Anywhere On Earth, which seems to be an IEEE informal standard. :)

I'll submit my article by then - the draft just needs a final re-read. (Unless I have one last go at debugging a fortran/C cross-compile that worked with g77 a decade ago and fails with gfortran today...)

[rougier]

For those interested, Nature made a report about the challenge: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02462-7

[ev-br]

Now we all need to add a citation to make it properly recursive

[rougier]

Also on hacker news: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24260337

[ebo]

I assume that the challenge is over for now. If not, this would be my submission:

Reference: Hargis, C.D., Bissonette, J.A., and David, J.L. "The behavior of landscape metrics commonly used in the study of habitat fragmentation." Landscape Ecology 13(3) 167-186 (1998). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.475237 Article age: 22 years Open access version: Confidence in success: medium. All source code came with TDD test suites, but it was 2008 the last time I rebuilt it.

The original article has been cited over 850 times in the primary literature (according to Google Scholar).

If the challenge is still open, let me know and I will see if I can break away some time to try to recompile this, and post how this is going. It is my interest/intent to rewrite this in python using dask and numba. It is likely that I will not have time to work on the rewrite until after the end of the year.

[rougier]

The challenge is over but you can ~no~ now submit a regular "reproduction report".

[pdebuyl]

Sorry @rougier for checking, but you intended to write "you can now submit ..." right?

[rougier]

Yes, you're right. Corrected.