gkiar
commented
5 years ago - [ ] Page 0:
- intro page seems generic across repronim, not really lesson specific? Doesn't seem to match the outline at the top
- put real timing estimates :)
- [ ] Page 1:
- a LOT of text/reading
- Could be more tied to examples, show the FAIR figure, introduce the principles, and discuss why each are necessary.
- This reads like a really nice essay on these topics, but is quite inaccessible for teaching. I'd recommend moving this somewhere, pointing to it, but giving the students a much more brief "tl;dr" on these topics, and again situate them in real examples so they immediately grok the relevance.
- Move BIDS and NIDM onto a new page (and add Boutiques for FAIR tools), since they're implementations aiming for FAIR rather than the principles/concept itself.
- [ ] Page 2: missing?
- [ ] Page 3:
- make more accessible; turn into case studies and thought provoking questions/real-world challenges.
- provide concrete examples of the state of data sharing in different parts of the world based on current legislation (this last bit tackles the theory in the next page)
- [ ] Page 4:
- like page 1, move reading to some other resource and, make the page easier to digest in an interactive/classroom setting.
- tie to concrete examples of what to and not to do.
- [ ] Page 5:
- fix some broken links
- Provide screenshots and "table" outlining pros and cons of each software, when you'd use something like loris or xnat over your own small mongodb
- case studies
- [ ] Page 6: difficult concept to truncate, but could be made more accessible with visual representations to go alongside the good tangible examples.