search

RfidResearchGroup / proxmark3

Iceman Fork - Proxmark3
http://www.icedev.se
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.81k stars 1.01k forks source link

iCLASS 2K wrbl not working #946

Closed jumpycalm closed 3 years ago

jumpycalm commented 4 years ago

Describe the bug Someone reported this issue on the Proxmark forum, I was never able to post anything on the forum, so I'm bring up the issue here. Basically I am seeing this issue: http://www.proxmark.org/forum/viewtopic.php?id=8089 The issue is not repro on the 16K iCLASS. The issue is only repro on the 2K iCLASS. I tried the 2K iCLASS from 3 sellers and I got the same problem. Please note, the iCLASS fobs I purchased are just regular fobs (Not SE, SEO etc.) with default key. I am able to read no problem and I am able to program the fob with the iclassfield + HID Omnikey reader no problem.

To Reproduce

hf ic wrbl b 6 d BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB k 0

Expected behavior Write to block 6 success

Screenshots

[usb] pm3 --> hf ic rdbl b 6 k 0

[+]  block 06 : AA AA AA AA AA AA AA AA

[usb] pm3 --> hf ic wrbl b 6 d BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB k 0
[+] Using key[0] AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78
[-] Writing failed
[usb] pm3 --> hf ic in

[=] --- Tag Information --------------------------
[=] -------------------------------------------------------------
[+]     CSN: A3 D7 BC 10 FE FF 12 E0   (uid)
[+]  Config: 12 FF FF FF 7F 1F FF 3C   (Card configuration)
[+] E-purse: FC FF FF FF FF FF FF FF   (Card challenge, CC)
[+]      Kd: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00   (Debit key, hidden)
[+]      Kc: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00   (Credit key, hidden)
[+]     AIA: FF FF FF FF FF FF FF FF   (Application Issuer area)
[=] ------ card configuration ------
[+]   Mode: Application (locked)
[+] Coding: ISO 14443-2 B / 15693
[+]  Crypt: Secured page, keys not locked
[=]     RA: Read access not enabled
[=] App limit 0x12, OTP 0xFFFF, Block write lock 0xFF
[=]      Chip 0x7F, Mem 0x1F, EAS 0xFF, Fuses 0x3C
[=] ------ Memory ------
[=]     2 KBits/2 App Areas (256 bytes)
[=]     AA1 blocks 13 { 0x06 - 0x12 (06 - 18) }
[=]     AA2 blocks 18 { 0x13 - 0x1F (19 - 31) }
[=] ------ KeyAccess ------
[=]  Kd = Debit key (AA1),  Kc = Credit key (AA2)
[=]      Read A - Kd or Kc
[=]      Read B - Kd or Kc
[=]     Write A - Kc
[=]     Write B - Kc
[=]       Debit - Kd or Kc
[=]      Credit - Kc
[=] ------ Fingerprint ------
[+] CSN is in HID range
[+] Credential : iCLASS legacy
[+]  Card type : PicoPass 2K
[usb] pm3 --> hf ic list
[=] downloading tracelog data from device
[+] Recorded activity (trace len = 292 bytes)
[=] start = start of start frame end = end of frame. src = source of transfer
[=] ISO15693 / iCLASS - all times are in carrier periods (1/13.56MHz)

      Start |        End | Src | Data (! denotes parity error)                                           | CRC | Annotation
------------+------------+-----+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----+--------------------
          0 |       5632 | Rdr |0a                                                                       |     | ACTALL
      17984 |      20032 | Tag |<SOF>                                                                    |     |
      24128 |      29760 | Rdr |0c                                                                       |     | IDENTIFY
      33472 |      78528 | Tag |fb  9c  17  c2  ff  5f  02  3c  01  d3                                   |  ok |
      82624 |     121024 | Rdr |81  fb  9c  17  c2  ff  5f  02  3c                                       |     | SELECT
     124736 |     169792 | Tag |d9  e7  bc  10  fe  ff  12  e0  14  d7                                   |  ok |
     173888 |     191808 | Rdr |0c  01  fa  22                                                           |  ok | READ(1)
     195520 |     240576 | Tag |12  ff  ff  ff  7f  1f  ff  3c  8c  87                                   |  ok |
     244672 |     262592 | Rdr |0c  05  de  64                                                           |  ok | READ(5)
       4160 |      49216 | Tag |ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ea  f5                                   |  ok |
      53312 |      63040 | Rdr |88  02                                                                   |     | READCHECK[Kd](2)
      66752 |     103616 | Tag |fc  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff  ff                                           |  ok |
     114240 |     152640 | Rdr |05  00  00  00  00  0e  3f  3a  16                                       |     | CHECK
     156352 |     176832 | Tag |7c  89  c6  73                                                           |  ok | ( AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78 )
     302720 |     369792 | Rdr |87  06  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  63  2f  97  ea  cd  dc           |     | UPDATE(6)
     588608 |     655680 | Rdr |87  06  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  63  2f  97  ea  cd  dc           |     | UPDATE(6)
     874496 |     941568 | Rdr |87  06  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  bb  63  2f  97  ea  cd  dc           |     | UPDATE(6)

Desktop (please complete the following information):

[+] Displaying LF tuning graph. Divisor 88 is 134.83 kHz, 95 is 125.00 kHz.



**Additional context**
Additional tests performed:
1. Tested on multiple Proxmark3 Easy as well as Proxmark3 RDV4, same result;
2. Tested the iCLASS fobs from multiple vendors, some of them are even order directly from HID dealer;
3. The iCLASS fobs I have are all programmed fobs with default key. But block 6 is not locked. I have no problem changing block 6 with iclassfield + HID Omnikey reader.
4. I tried to debug this issue myself, but I went to a dead end. I put some debug output in my code, I found that the authentication passed. i.e. I was using the correct key. But the write operation failed at iclass_send_cmd_with_retries(). I tried to increase the retry counts as well as play around with the delays, but no success.
iceman1001 commented 4 years ago

Works like a charm for me. I can see in your commands you don't use b 06 , where you need to have the blocknumber as 2 hex symbols, like stated in the helptext.

Maybe you don't have the correct key? 

[usb] pm3 --> hf icl in

[=] --- Tag Information --------------------------
[=] -------------------------------------------------------------
[+]     CSN: 32 B3 D5 00 F7 FF 12 E0   (uid)
[+]  Config: 12 FF FF FF 7F 1F FF 3C   (Card configuration)
[+] E-purse: 8A FE FF FF FF FF FF FF   (Card challenge, CC)
[+]      Kd: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00   (Debit key, hidden)
[+]      Kc: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00   (Credit key, hidden)
[+]     AIA: FF FF FF FF FF FF FF FF   (Application Issuer area)
[=] ------ card configuration ------
[+]   Mode: Application (locked)
[+] Coding: ISO 14443-2 B / 15693
[+]  Crypt: Secured page, keys not locked
[=]     RA: Read access not enabled
[=] App limit 0x12, OTP 0xFFFF, Block write lock 0xFF
[=]      Chip 0x7F, Mem 0x1F, EAS 0xFF, Fuses 0x3C
[=] ------ Memory ------
[=]     2 KBits/2 App Areas (256 bytes)
[=]     AA1 blocks 13 { 0x06 - 0x12 (06 - 18) }
[=]     AA2 blocks 18 { 0x13 - 0x1F (19 - 31) }
[=] ------ KeyAccess ------
[=]  Kd = Debit key (AA1),  Kc = Credit key (AA2)
[=]      Read A - Kd or Kc
[=]      Read B - Kd or Kc
[=]     Write A - Kc
[=]     Write B - Kc
[=]       Debit - Kd or Kc
[=]      Credit - Kc
[=] ------ Fingerprint ------
[+] CSN is in HID range
[+] Credential : iCLASS legacy
[+]  Card type : PicoPass 2K
[usb] pm3 --> hf iclass wr
Write data to a iCLASS tag

Usage:  hf iclass wrbl b <block> d <data> k <key> [c|e|r|v]

Options:
  h         : Show this help
  b <block> : The block number as 2 hex symbols
  d <data>  : set the Data to write as 16 hex symbols
  k <key>   : access Key as 16 hex symbols or 1 hex to select key from memory
  c         : credit key assumed

  e         : elite computations applied to key
  r         : raw, no computations applied to key (raw)
  v         : verbose output
Examples:
        hf iclass wrbl b 0A d AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA k 001122334455667B
        hf iclass wrbl b 1B d AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA k 001122334455667B c
        hf iclass wrbl b 1B d AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA k 0

[usb] pm3 --> hf iclass wr b 0c d 0102030405060708 k 0
[+] Using key[0] AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78

[+] Wrote block 0C successful
[usb] pm3 -->
[usb] pm3 -->
[usb] pm3 --> hf iclas wr b 06 d bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb k 0
[+] Using key[0] AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78
[+] Wrote block 06 successful
[usb] pm3 --> hf iclass rd b 06 k 0

[+]  block 06 : BB BB BB BB BB BB BB BB

[usb] pm3 --> hf iclas list

Run the check command against your tag hf iclass chk f iclass_default_keys

jumpycalm commented 4 years ago

Thank you Iceman! Same result for using 2 hex symbol and I do have the correct key:

[usb] pm3 --> hf ic wrbl b 06 d BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB k 0
[+] Using key[0] AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78
[-] Writing failed
[usb] pm3 --> hf iclass chk f iclass_default_keys
[+] loaded  7 keys from dictionary file /home/m9/rrg/client/dictionaries/iclass_default_keys.dic
[+] Reading tag CSN / CCNR...
[+]     CSN: D9 E7 BC 10 FE FF 12 E0
[+]    CCNR: FC FF FF FF FF FF FF FF 00 00 00 00
[+] Generating diversified keys
[+] Searching for DEBIT key...

[+] Found valid key AE A6 84 A6 DA B2 32 78

[+] time in iclass chk 1 seconds
[+] Key already at keyslot 0

Please note, the issue only reproducible with 2K iCLASS but not reproducible with 16K iCLASS. It works like a charm for me for any of my 16K iCLASS. I think jramb0 who reported this issue on the forum also using a 2K iCLASS. Do you have any 2K iCLASS you can try? [+] Card type : PicoPass 2K

iceman1001 commented 4 years ago

My test was with a 

[=] ------ Fingerprint ------
[+] CSN is in HID range
[+] Credential : iCLASS legacy
[+]  Card type : PicoPass 2K

Did you have some distance between reader and tag?

jumpycalm commented 4 years ago

Yes, I always put a sticky notes about 8mm thick between the reader and the tag for optimal reading and writing performance. Maybe I can send you some iCLASS tags I have to you to see if you can repro the issue? I can find your email address on the forum. I believe I am not the only one who is seeing this issue based on someone's post on the forum.

iceman1001 commented 4 years ago

80mm? 8cm is quite far. I guess you meant 8mm.

Feel free to send some iCLASS tag,

jumpycalm commented 4 years ago

Sorry, it's a typo. I will email you regarding the address to send the tags to. Hope you can get a repro. I tried to fix the issue from source code myself, I spent a day on it, no success.

iceman1001 commented 3 years ago

I may get a HID reader/writer, and will be able to verify if the timings for writing is long enough.

iceman1001 commented 3 years ago

Thanks! I found the problem and pushed a fix. Try it out