Open randyman99 opened 1 year ago
RinCat
commented
1 year ago Your system should not broken by remove gcc, in fact it is not installed by default.
And distro-watch-(something) not exists in ubuntu packages. I am not sure what was that since google find nothing.
randyman99
commented
1 year ago @RinCat , I agree that uninstalling and installing gcc should not have broken Ubuntu, and I can't say for sure that was the cause, but that was exactly when my problems started, and they went downhill from there within a matter of minutes.On the other hand, it could have been the faulty compile that stepped on some code it shouldn't have. But why was there that minor difference in the compiler and why should that make a difference? I've used a lot of C compilers over the decades and never had one be so finicky. I also don't know what the distro-watch was about, and that seemed bizarre, but at the Ubuntu maintenance mode level, that's what prevented me from continuing into a normal boot. Sorry I don't have exact notes, as I was copying and pasting from the terminal window when it crashed.
RinCat
commented
1 year ago @randyman99 Since different versions of compilers may generate binary with incompatible internal data structures, the use of different versions of compilers is prohibited in linux build scripts. This is not under the control of this driver, because the build uses the script that comes with the linux kernel source code instead of calling the compiler directly.
randyman99
commented
1 year ago @RinCat, exactly. You make a very good argument for why the user should not be depended upon to compile the source code. I could not agree more.
A warning to others… I bricked my system trying to install this. Granted, it wasn’t the instructions listed here per se, but those did not work for me. I followed this set as listed on the TP-Link website, copying the instructions into a script and running that.
sudo apt update
sudo apt install -y dkms git
sudo git clone 'https://github.com/RinCat/RTL88x2BU-Linux-Driver.git' /usr/src/rtl88x2bu-git
sudo sed -i 's/PACKAGE_VERSION="@PKGVER@"/PACKAGE_VERSION="git"/g' /usr/src/rtl88x2bu-git/dkms.conf
sudo dkms add -m rtl88x2bu -v git
sudo dkms autoinstall
sudo reboot
When it rebooted, my T4U still did not work (I had just upgraded to 22.04, Linux 5.15.0-71-generic x86_64). I put pauses after each step in the script and ran it again, and saw there was a problem with the makefile. It said the version of gcc I was using was not the same one that was used to create the module, but it continued to run anyway. I looked at the log file, and there were quite a few errors. I had run “sudo update” as the first instruction in the script, so I didn’t understand why gcc was not the most current. You’ll forgive me if I don’t have the exact text, as my system was bricked and it’s all gone. I had gcc version 4.x.y (Ubuntu 22.04), and the version used to build the module was gcc 4.x.y (Ubuntu1 22.04). They both had the same version/revision number, the only difference being the Ubuntu vs. Ubuntu1. So how do I get the right version? I tried installing it, but apt said I already had the most current version. I uninstalled gcc and then reinstalled it, and that seemingly innocuous act may have been my big mistake. Now the computer complained that distro-watch-(something) was not the most recent. I ignored that (perhaps also a seemingly innocuous act that was a mistake), and tried rerunning the script to build the T4U module, but it again failed. I again got a warning that distro-watch-(something) was not current. I again ignored it and returned to the Tp-Link page to document my actions and what was not working, while I still had all the information. In the middle of typing, the page disappeared. Okay, I’ll write it in a document and copy and paste it. As I was writing the document, the system went into spontaneous reboot.
When the reboot progressed from Grub, Ubuntu never came back. I rebooted into Ubuntu maintenance mode, and selected to repair dkms. I looked at the details beforehand, and it said three distro-watch-(something) packages needed to be repaired. I selected to repair them, and when that finished, it still wouldn’t boot into Ubuntu. I went into maintenance mode again, and it said the same three distro-watch-(something) packages needed to be repaired. I selected to repair them. When it finished, I selected to repair dkms again, and it said the same three packages needed to be repaired. I went into the same loop several times until I was convinced this was going nowhere, i.e., this installation of Ubuntu was bricked.
Luckily, I had installed another installation of Ubuntu 20.04 in another partition set on this computer before I upgraded. I rebooted into that, and everything is fine. I’ve already deleted the offending 22.04 installation, reinstalled Grub, and also removed the 22.04 logical volumes, volume group, and physical volume. I’m good with staying with 20.04 on this computer with the T4U dongle. I was in the process of moving 22.04 to a new computer I had just purchased (with onboard WiFi), and thankfully I had finished the critical steps of that process before this happened.