River-Zhang / SIFU

[CVPR 2024 Highlight] Official repository for paper "SIFU: Side-view Conditioned Implicit Function for Real-world Usable Clothed Human Reconstruction"
https://river-zhang.github.io/SIFU-projectpage/
MIT License
206 stars 9 forks source link

The test results of the pre-trained model are inconsistent with the benchmark #7

Closed glorioushonor closed 8 months ago

glorioushonor commented 8 months ago

Hello, I have successfully tested the pre-trained model, but I found that the results do not match the data in the benchmark, especially for CAPE-NFP. Is this normal? Looking forward to your reply. image

River-Zhang commented 8 months ago

It seems that you're using the whole cape dataset (containing 150 scans) rather than cape-NFP (containing 100 scans). Besides we did not refer to cape-easy or cape-hard. We just sum the results and calculate the average. image Here is the testing result for the whole cape dataset. You can test again on CAPE-NFP (I guess it's in pose.txt?)

glorioushonor commented 8 months ago

It seems that you're using the whole cape dataset (containing 150 scans) rather than cape-NFP (containing 100 scans). Besides we did not refer to cape-easy or cape-hard. We just sum the results and calculate the average. image Here is the testing result for the whole cape dataset. You can test again on CAPE-NFP (I guess it's in pose.txt?)

In my opinion, the contents of pose.txt are consistent with the last 100 data entries in all.txt. The first fifty entries in all.txt are cape-easy, which is essentially CAPE-FP; the last one hundred entries in all.txt are cape-hard, which is essentially CAPE-NFP.

accu_outputs = accumulate(
            outputs,
            rot_num=3,
            split={
                "cape-easy": (0, 50),
                "cape-hard": (50, 150)
            },
        )
River-Zhang commented 8 months ago

Let me check out this

River-Zhang commented 8 months ago

I tested on CAPE-NFP solely and the result is image and the whole cape dataset image

It seems that I might have released an old version ckpt. I'll change to the correct one as soon as possible.

River-Zhang commented 8 months ago

I have updated the ckpt (https://1drv.ms/u/s!AtYZWFVkmRdwnEDF5XGtfLVzgLsH?e=bpgsji). You can test this again. Thanks very much!

glorioushonor commented 8 months ago

I have updated the ckpt (https://1drv.ms/u/s!AtYZWFVkmRdwnEDF5XGtfLVzgLsH?e=bpgsji). You can test this again. Thanks very much!

@River-Zhang Thanks. The test results of the pre-trained model are exactly the same as yours. However, the results of my own training are very poor, and I don't know why. Was your pre-trained model only trained for 10 epochs? image

River-Zhang commented 7 months ago

Yes, it is trained only 10 epochs.