RobinHankin / hyper2

5 stars 3 forks source link

surfing and Journal of Sports Analytics #105

Closed RobinHankin closed 8 months ago

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

it would be good to rejig surfing.Rmdfor submission to JSA. The current one contains a hodgepodge of results and needs to be lean and mean before we can submit it.

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

Submitted surfing_jsa.pdf [which is from surfing_jsa.tex] to JSA which is now MS596. Following email (to hankin.robin@gmail.com) received 30 August 2021:

Dear robin,

Thank you for your submission, MS 596, entitled

"Analysis of competitive surfing tournaments with reified Bradley-Terry likelihoods"

which was received on August 26, 2021. Eugene Shen has been assigned as the coeditor in charge of your submission.

Please refer to the manuscript number, MS 596, in any future correspondence concerning your submission. You can contact Eugene Shen directly by email at eugene.shen@gmail.com to find out the status of your submission.

You can also check the status of your submission at any time by visiting the following url (if your email does not support built-in hyperlinks, copy this url into your browser window and bookmark it, taking care not to split the long url or allow intervening spaces: this url has a security password so that only you will be able to access the status info on your submission).

https://editorialexpress.com/s.cgi?i=d3bda84f8fde2229e4f7c763bda1a567

Normally you should expect to wait about 12 weeks before referees have returned reports and a decision can be made.

Sincerely,

Philip Maymin and Eugene Shen

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

see e1fbdda

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

See 0417704faad2c1905f9253e9d27fdeedeb819f83

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

Will open a new issue specifically for the second referee's comment

RobinHankin commented 2 years ago

submitted a revised manuscript (anonymised), the result of surfing_jsa.tex with names removed, and also the rebuttal, the result of surfing_jsa_rebuttal_referee2.tex. I received an acknowledgement of this from JSA, to my gmail account, just now

RobinHankin commented 1 year ago

Emailed Eugene Shen to enquire of the status of the manuscript:

Dear Professor Shen

I am writing about manuscript JSA-596 "Analysis of competitive surfing tournaments..." by Driver and Hankin. I tried to check its status on the JSA submission website, but it said that it did not recognise the submission. Can you advise? I worry that I have missed a communication from you; my last contact with you was in April this year.

Best wishes

Robin

RobinHankin commented 1 year ago

Eugene Shen replies via gmail, 3 August 2022:

I sent it back to the original reviewers. Thanks!

RobinHankin commented 1 year ago

automatic email from JSA [to gmail; 4 Aug 2022] reminding me that one of my attempted submissions did not work and they are going to delete it if I don't pick it up

RobinHankin commented 8 months ago

now published, closing issue.