search

Roblox / future-is-bright

Prototyping future Roblox lighting technology
https://roblox.github.io/future-is-bright/
60 stars 12 forks source link

Compatibility Issue with Voxel and Future is Bright lighting #136

Closed popomcnuggets closed 4 years ago

popomcnuggets commented 5 years ago

The new Voxel mode is a great option for a wide variety of environmental lighting. However, some of the new additions to the lighting should be separated as an option, as they might limit the options a developer has. Here are some comparisons below that may show what I mean:

Image A (the Legacy classic lighting, with global shadows on as with all of these images): image

Image B (the Voxel option in regular Studio mode): image

Image C (Voxel lighting with various adjustments, such as ColorCorrection and ambient changes): image

Image D (the Future is Bright alternative Studio mode): image

Image E (Future is Bright with various adjustments, such as ColorCorrection and ambient changes): image

I have a few objects in these images to represent the environment that I have. With the voxel lighting and recent Future is Bright options, I feel that the colors have less saturation. This may be due to contrast changes, saturation changes, exposure, or the material adjustments. I attempted to undo the changes in the images, but they cannot be fully reversed. I made this thread in the hopes that the new lighting can be used, with a toggleable option to reverse the mentioned changes.

popomcnuggets commented 5 years ago

P.S.: I apologize if this post was rude or caused any inconvenience. Thank you.

GreenEggsAndGeno commented 5 years ago

As a roblox developer i dont see a reason not to add this in. Personally theres a problem to adjust the lighting to be to my liking but it doesnt bother me that much, but I get what you are trying to achieve here. I didn't know the lighting would be so limited.

zeux commented 4 years ago

FIB is going to become a public Studio beta in official Roblox Studio distribution in a few weeks.

Watch the announcements on dev. forum - once we post the beta we'll welcome the feedback on the beta, including bug reports that may still be there etc., on dev. forum.

Thanks for helping us get Future Is Bright closer to release!