RobokopU24 / Feedback

Feedback on the ROBOKOP project
https://robokop.renci.org
0 stars 0 forks source link

Unify robokop Kg and robokopkg graphs. #143

Closed karafecho closed 4 months ago

karafecho commented 1 year ago

Please see my last two posts in RobokopU24/Use-Cases#10. I haven't been able to replicate Jon-Michael's ExEmplar results using ROBOKOP qgraph. Note that the screenshots I captured include only a few of the queries I tried. In addition to testing a variety of predicates and nodes (e.g., herpes zoster vs shingles), I tested several different chemical entity selections (i.e., from the duplicates in the drop-down list).

I'm not expecting results for all five of the input chemical entities, but I wouldn't think that would break a query.

Subsequent troubleshooting with Jon-Michael revealed the following.

This ExEmplar query hits the ROBOKOP KG Neo4j db directly and returns results:

image

This ROBOKOP qgraph query does not return results:

image

Same query as the ExEmplar one, but run in the Neo4j browser, with results returned:

image

Same query as the ExEmplar one, but posted to ROBOKOP KG on Automat, with no results returned:

image

I'm thinking this might be a Cypher to ROBOKOP qgraph / TRAPI translation issue?

EvanDietzMorris commented 1 year ago

This was due to content differences between the graphs hosted at robokopkg.renci.org (the graph exemplar queried) and robokopkg on Automat (the graph qgraph queried).

karafecho commented 1 year ago

I think this needs to be reconciled. We should not have two different versions of ROBOKOP KG.

karafecho commented 1 year ago

Moreover, we've branded robokopkg.renci.org as the ROBOKOP KG, so that endpoint should be ground truth.

karafecho commented 1 year ago

Decision on 04/10/2023: robokopkg.renci.org and http://automat.renci.org/#/robokopkg will point to duplicate copies of a new ROBOKOP KG that will include the existing Automat ROBOKOP KG plus Text Miner KG (but not CORD19 KG).

cbizon commented 4 months ago

I think that this has been implemented.