RobotWithFeelings / CSC710_Project

Repo CSC710 Project
0 stars 0 forks source link

Comments on the proposal draft #1

Closed botwithfeelings closed 8 years ago

botwithfeelings commented 8 years ago

@meneal, the proposal draft looks really good and close to the final submission. Nonetheless, here are my thoughts on the proposal draft. Feel free to let me know which of these seem worthy of being included in the draft.

First two paragraphs:

See my changes in ShareLatex for the first two paragraphs, feel free to change them as you see fit. I have your changes in block comments untouched.

Proposed study:

The part involving our study roadmap should have the following goals:

I made some changes in SharLatex according to this, check them to see if you like these. We can further discuss on the changes on github or in person.

meneal commented 8 years ago

The changes so far I think are awesome. I made a few grammatical changes throughout. We have personalization throughout the paper in a weird way though I think. Should that not be personification?

I also shortened the title. Seemed to me that should be enough, what do you think?

Overall I think the changes are great and what you've put up here for requirements for proposed study and first two paragraphs are really helpful to me.

On Mon, Jan 18, 2016 at 4:57 PM, Shaown Sarker notifications@github.com wrote:

@meneal https://github.com/meneal, the proposal draft looks really good and close to the final submission Nonetheless, here are my thoughts on the proposal draft Feel free to let me know which of these seem worthy of being included in the draft First two paragraphs:

-

One point I learned so far from the reading groups is that every paragraph should focus on a single goal statement The first paragraph here is to focus on Nass' study and it's results The second sentence seems to point to the results but it's not explicitly mentioned (last part of the second sentence - in this way)

The subject population demographic of the study is not required here I think The second paragraph should focus on why it is worthwhile to do Nass' study again now as the access to computers has become more common

See my changes in ShareLatex for the first two paragraphs, feel free to change them as you see fit I have your changes in block comments untouched Proposed study:

The part involving our study roadmap should have the following goals:

  • What we will do
  • What is our expected results
  • What are the challenges of performing the study, if any

I made some changes in SharLatex according to this, check them to see if you like these We can further discuss on the changes on github or in person

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/RobotWithFeelings/CSC710_Project/issues/1.

botwithfeelings commented 8 years ago

We submitted our proposal and got it reviewed by Dr. E. Closing this.