RonitT1234 / JARV_Frontend

Passion Project Frontend
MIT License
2 stars 0 forks source link

Passion Project Grading #4

Open RonitT1234 opened 11 months ago

RonitT1234 commented 11 months ago

HOOK (Points: 3.6-4.0) (Key features achieved) Reason: Grade:

KNOWLEDGE (Points: 3.6-4.0) (How it's made, demo showed) Reason: Grade:

VALUE( Points: 0.6-1.0) (Most useful or valuable aspect of project) Reason: Grade:

WOW FACTOR (How amazing is our project) Comment:

trevorhuang1 commented 11 months ago

Usage of:

HOOK (Points: 3.6-4.0) (Key features achieved) Reason: Got me engaged from the start with a colorful title screen and a pokemon card opening. Only thing I didn't like was that the default theme didn't really match your project. Grade: 3.9/4.0

KNOWLEDGE (Points: 3.6-4.0) (How it's made, demo showed) Reason: Use of database, agile (multiple plans made), and frontend/backend connection. Grade: 4.0/4.0

VALUE( Points: 0.6-1.0) (Most useful or valuable aspect of project) Reason: The search feature is genuinely useful for any pokemon fans out there and the games are fun but have some glitches. Grade: 0.8/1.0

WOW FACTOR (How amazing is our project) Comment: Fun project with database, engaging game, decent design, and a quiz on top of all that.

LincolnC2008 commented 11 months ago

Hook (Points: 3.6-4.0) (Key features achieved) It was a really cool idea to make something on Pokémon and the card opening you did was a really engaging part of it. I personally don't see anything wrong with it as I thought it was a fun/unique and well executed idea. 4.0/4.0

KNOWLEDGE (Points: 3.6-4.0) (How it's made, demo showed) Your use of plans and the database for storing the Pokémon info as well as the API connection of Frontend and Backend. 4.0/4.0

VALUE( Points: 0.6-1.0) (Most useful or valuable aspect of project) I think if you love Pokémon this could be an amazing site, could use a little cleaning up though. Another problem is how this site is specific to only people that like Pokémon. 0.8/1.0

WOW FACTOR (How amazing is our project) Like I said, very fun and unique idea with multiple features.

Total: 8.8/9.0

will-w-cheng commented 11 months ago

Hook (4/4) - I thought it was really cool how they took a simple idea such as POKEMON and engaged everyone in it such heavily and deeply. I'm pretty sure everyone enjoyed the project and loved how it was done.

knowledge (3.85/4) - The API connection and use of multiple ones being pulled within the backend and frontend is clearly done and well shown. The code is also well thought out and shows extensive knowledge of different operations for the cards. I would've liked to hear more about how the integration was done but overall, well done.

Value (1) + WOW factor The value and ability to bring such a card like Pokemon and expand the project really far and bring it throughout a bunch of different features on the website and aspects was done amazingly and I really loved it. It brought back a lot of memories and targetted the audience extremely well

Total: 8.85 / 9

SriS126 commented 11 months ago

HOOK (Points: 3.6-4.0) (Key features achieved) Reason: Really engaging, they caught my eye and welcomed me into the passion project, allowed me to interact with different stuff Grade: 3.95/4

KNOWLEDGE (Points: 3.6-4.0) (How it's made, demo showed) Reason: Showed all of the code and who did what, could've went more in depth with explaining but explained a brief overview of the code. Grade: 3.9/4

VALUE( Points: 0.6-1.0) (Most useful or valuable aspect of project) + WOW Factor Reason: A really unique passion project which will get API's from Pokemon and display them onto cards, can be useful simulating opening a pack and see what your chances of getting a card are. Design of the passion project is intriguing. Grade: 1/1

8.85/9