Rplus / Pokemon-shiny

Share personal shiny pokemon by URL!
https://rplus.github.io/Pokemon-shiny/
MIT License
83 stars 31 forks source link

Is the detective Pikachu image wrong? #280

Closed Evillunte closed 11 months ago

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

Is the shiny image wrong. ? Just open my costume dex and see 2 Pikachu detective and two detective raichu.

The old detective Pikachu ( was not out in shiny . The new one we just had, was shiny, and it has a glass in the hand. (The old was without glass in the hand)

The image on the shiny checklist is without glass (dont know if there is a image with glass in the hand)

IMG_20231106_153145

Screenshot_2023-11-06-15-46-15-27_8a5f4726f7453c77b8d93615cedb556d

Screenshot_2023-11-06-15-50-14-50_8a5f4726f7453c77b8d93615cedb556d

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

If you click on the Pikachu in the event dex,you also se them with and without glass

MelkyAir commented 11 months ago

The sprites are the same, only the animation is different. It doesn't make a difference for the shiny list. Was also discussed briefly in pokeminers issue: https://github.com/PokeMiners/pogo_assets/issues/56

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

The link dont work. Just think, when niantic give them two different places in the dex,it could give problem in the future

BartmanEH commented 11 months ago

https://github.com/PokeMiners/pogo_assets/issues/56 I'm not sure what the issue is. I swapped out the old image which was released the first time Detective Pika was released and everyone thought it would be available as shiny but turned out not to be. The image in the shiny check list is the newly released asset.

BartmanEH commented 11 months ago

Is the shiny image wrong. ? Just open my costume dex and see 2 Pikachu detective and two detective raichu.

The old detective Pikachu ( was not out in shiny . The new one we just had, was shiny, and it has a glass in the hand. (The old was without glass in the hand)

The image on the shiny checklist is without glass (dont know if there is a image with glass in the hand)

IMG_20231106_153145

This must be some kind of bug in the game. I don't think it makes sense to add another copy to the checklist since you can't actually get the original in shiny anyway.

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

Like melkyair say, the animations is different on those two... And The animations is being show both in your pokemon bag and in the dex. But everything else is the same

Hope its a bug that both is in the event dex. And niantic dont release the old in shiny also. What would be a problem .

Wonder if there is a image with the magnifying glass.?

BartmanEH commented 11 months ago

I still don't understand what you are suggesting we should do. With the new version, the magnifying glass only shows during animation. We don't show animations in the checklist, we show static image only. The static image asset doesn't have a magnifying glass. All this relates to the bug where Niantic forgot to turn on the shiny for the first release and the asset has been available all along. Since the original is not available, there's nothing to collect right now and nothing to be done in the checklist until something changes like they actually release the original or something.

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

Sorry my bad english, not good to write or talk it . In from Denmark.

know we dont show animation in the checklist, but only image. but maybe there was a image with the magnifying glass.

I can understand on you last message there is not a image with the glass👍, so i close this.

( some people on google say detective was shortly out in shiny the first time, but it was a mistake from niantic,and the remove it again)

BartmanEH commented 11 months ago

I totally agree--pretty sure it was a mistake by Niantic. Don't worry about your English--it's perfectly adequate for our intentions here! I was just trying to understand if there was a real action we should take on this issue.

Evillunte commented 11 months ago

Thx... Just wonder if a image of a Pikachu with magnifying glass was the best solution if its not was a bug from niantic. But there is no, so no problem...