DCEG 1.2.0_1.3.0 Portrayal Gap Analysis - Githubissues

S-101-Portrayal-subWG / Working-Documents

16 stars 5 forks source link

DCEG 1.2.0_1.3.0 Portrayal Gap Analysis #161

Closed alvarosanuy closed 2 months ago

alvarosanuy commented 4 months ago

Below is the first S-101 PC Gap analysis draft with my inputs.

DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis@13MAR2024.docx

alvarosanuy commented 4 months ago

Updated with comments from TR

DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis@13MAR2024 TR.docx

DavidGrant-NIWC commented 3 months ago

Added NIWC comments

DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis@13MAR2024.NIWC.docx

alvarosanuy commented 3 months ago

Final list based on DCEG version 20240405 uploaded to 'Documentation' GitHub space on 09042024. DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis@09APR2024.docx

New entries in red and yellow Highlight

alvarosanuy commented 3 months ago

Version post 10/04/24 Meeting - Entries to be completed by COB Friday 19APR2024

DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis@10APR2024.docx

alvarosanuy commented 3 months ago

Decisions made at Portrayal subWG meeting on 10/04/24

Members to provide input by COB Friday 19APR2024 (for full assessments, please add a column to the document and upload a new version when done). Limited feedback to existing entries can be provided as comments in this Issue.
[x] Alvaro to consolidate 'Way Forward" and discuss with NIWC (by Wednesday 24/04/24).
[ ] NIWC to commence required edits to PC 1.2.3 and work towards a release of PC 1.3.0 for Peer Review (1 week) on 08/05/24. The S101PT Delivery Plan towards S-101 2.0.0 requires us to release the final version of PC 1.3.0 by 17/05/24.

alvarosanuy commented 3 months ago

My assessment:

DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis_Final_V1.docx

mikan66 commented 3 months ago

NIWC comments with assigned PC issues: DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis_Final_V1_NIWC.docx

alvarosanuy commented 3 months ago

Final version for implementation (based on last column's entries): DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis_Final_V2_Consolidated.docx

[ ] NIWC to commence required edits to PC 1.2.3 and work towards a release of PC 1.3.0 for Peer Review (1 week) on 08/05/24. The S101PT Delivery Plan towards S-101 2.0.0 requires us to release the final version of PC 1.3.0 by 17/05/24.

alvarosanuy commented 2 months ago

Anything still pending implementation from this spreadsheet?

Note that Hierarchy of Metadata has been resolved and MSC.530 has its own Issue to track progress.

mikan66 commented 2 months ago

Final version for implementation (based on last column's entries): DCEG.1.2.0_1.3.0.Portrayal.Gap.Analysis_Final_V2_Consolidated.docx

[ ] NIWC to commence required edits to PC 1.2.3 and work towards a release of PC 1.3.0 for Peer Review (1 week) on 08/05/24. The S101PT Delivery Plan towards S-101 2.0.0 requires us to release the final version of PC 1.3.0 by 17/05/24.

We had entered issues based on last column and those issues are completed and closed in 1.3.0-PR. I don't see any deferred past 1.3.0.

DavidGrant-NIWC commented 2 months ago

Note that Hierarchy of Metadata has been resolved

It's resolved from the PSWG perspective, but it's not implemented in PC 1.3 (because it's not currently needed). It's more of a DCEG and PC issue depending on the outcome of the MSC.530 issue.