search

SAA-SDT / EAD3

https://www.loc.gov/ead/index.html
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
80 stars 25 forks source link

Clarification re: validation needed #501

Open rockivist opened 8 years ago

rockivist commented 8 years ago

Following up on a discussion on Twitter where someone asked me and @ruthtillman about this, there is a need for documentation for how to validate EAD3 files. In particular, we need to clarify the role of the namespace (http://ead3.archivists.org/schema/) vs. the file path for the schema.

Lots of people are accustomed to validating EAD 2002 against the copy of the schema or DTD hosted at loc.gov. Now that we are hosting the code at GitHub, it is possible to validate against that copy (to which the namespace redirects), but it might be wiser to host a copy oft he schema locally.

Validation declarations in EAD instances vary from XSD, RNG, and DTD - we should clarify that as well. Would also be helpful to provide some guideance on creating Oxygen validation scenarios, especially on incorporating the ead3.sch Schematron.

For @karinbredenberg and Kathy to take up when we get TS-EAS organized.

kerstarno commented 4 years ago

Issue review in preparation to upcoming EAD subteam call on 23 September:

We might want to consider wrapping this into one issue together with EAD3 #467, i.e. aiming at a more general documentation on the topic of validation.

@karinbredenberg and @fordmadox - might this rather be an issue for the Schema subteam?

kerstarno commented 4 years ago

During their meeting on 28 October, EAD team of TS-EAS decided to assign this issue along with issues #467 and #508 to @fordmadox as team lead of the Schema team to indicate ownership being with that team.

Given that Schematron is only used with EAD3 at the moment, there remains, however, a close connection to the EAD team in finalising these issues.