SAA-SDT / EAS-TagLibraries

Tag Libraries for Encoded Archival Description Version 3 and Encoded Archival Context: Corporate Bodies, Persons, and Families
7 stars 5 forks source link

Create and update TEI XML files (group 2) as part of creating a draft EAD 4.0 Tag Library #136

Closed kerstarno closed 1 month ago

kerstarno commented 3 months ago

Creator of issue

  1. Kerstin Arnold
  2. TS-EAS member, EAD team lead
  3. @kerstarno

The issue relates to

Wanted change/feature

kerstarno commented 3 months ago

Couldn't find @erickcardosomx as a member of the SAA-SDT workspace, so tagging him here.

fordmadox commented 2 months ago

@alexduryee , @karinbredenberg , @kerstarno : I think I may have missed how we're providing differences with EAD and EAC in the current TL. in the examples that I've seen, it looks like 'type' is being supplied to paragraph elements. But that TEI element doesn't support that attribute, does it? See https://tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/ref-p.html. I'll likely go with a slightly different approach for now in my branch, to keep things valid according to TEI, but we can discuss before merging the two.

karinbredenberg commented 2 months ago

@fordmadox we are using our own TEI schema which isnt totally following TEI from the beginning so therefore we have done that solution.

When the elements/attributes are shared fingers crossed there is no need for differences.

fordmadox commented 2 months ago

Ohhh... I see now how that's handled in the transformation process (is our version of TEI defined anywhere so that the input can be validated?). Anyhow, I'll revert my branch to invalid TEI, in that case.

fordmadox commented 2 months ago

For my previous question: I see now that it is defined in this repository, but I don't think it's up to date with our current process. I'll hold off on updating that since I'm not sure how it's used, but that schema should likely include our use of 'type' in a few different areas not currently allowed. e.g. https://github.com/SAA-SDT/EAS-TagLibraries/blob/ead4/schema/tagLibrary_elementDesc.rng#L73

fordmadox commented 2 months ago

I was planning to use @subtype on the divs to keep everything nice and standard (TEI). Perhaps an option in the future, depending on how we add EAF, as well as support for generating PDF/UA output, etc.

fordmadox commented 2 months ago

I'm sure there are typos to fix, etc., but here's a pull request for a the few remaining updates needed from group 2: https://github.com/SAA-SDT/EAS-TagLibraries/pull/142