<sourceEntry> - Githubissues

SJagodzinski commented 4 years ago

Source Entry

remove element from EAC-CPF and replace with <reference>

Creator of issue

Silke Jagodzinski
TS-EAS: EAC-CPF subgroup
silkejagodzinski@gmail.com

Related issues / documents

Proposal to deprecate or remove and use instead #139

EAD3 Reconciliation

Additional EAD 3 attributes @altrender - Optional @audience - Optional (values limited to: external, internal) @encodinganalog - Optional @script - Optional

Context

A textual identification, such as a title, for a particular source of evidence used to establish the description of the CPF entity in the EAC-CPF instance.

May contain: [text] May occur within: <source> Attributes: @scriptCode, @transliteration, @xml:id, @xml:lang - all optional Availability: Optional, Repeatable

Solution documentation

remove from Tag Library

kerstarno commented 4 years ago

Schema test feedback - tested <sourceEntry> as this is still available in the schemas (RNG and XSD) in the "development" branch; PENDING decision as to whether this should be replaced by <reference>, see also #139, for which there is a variation of the schemas, both RNG and XSD, in the "issue 107" branch (https://github.com/SAA-SDT/eac-cpf-schema/tree/issue/107/xml-schemas/eac-cpf)

Tested against the updated set of attributes, which should be:

@audience - optional (values limited to: external, internal)
@id - optional
@languageOfElement - optional
@scriptOfElement - optional
@vocabularySource - optional
@vocabularySourceURI - optional
@valueURI - optional
@transliteration should NOT be available anymore as it was decided to remove the attribute and to indicate the transliteration scheme in <conventionDeclaration>, which bears the question if <sourceEntry> - provided it would be kept - needs to allow for @conventionDeclarationReference (note: there already is an exception to the rule of not having the assertion attributes within <control> as <term> does allow for these attributes as well due to being used in <control> and in <cpfDescription>

Test result (for both, RNG and XSD):

<sourceEntry> is required and cannot be repeated
<sourceEntry> can have text
<sourceEntry> allows for the optional attributes @audience, @id, @languageOfElement, @scriptOfElement, @vocabularySource, @vocabularySourceURI, @valueURI, as well as for the inclusion of several attributes from another namespace (tried with "show" and "actuate" from XLink)

Test successful.

kerstarno commented 3 years ago

As a note after having retested #107 - <sourceEntry> has been replaced with <reference> as the required (and repeatable) sub-element of <source>, i.e. <sourceEntry> is not available anymore in EAC-CPF 2.0.

SAA-SDT / eac-cpf-schema