Fig. 3 and associated analysis

[teixeirak]

@mcgregorian1 , for Fig. 3, could you please:

• [x] increase font size
• [x] maybe add letters, color coded by drought, indicating species differences?

The text in the results on this figure currently reads, "Drought resistance also varied across species, overall and in each drought year (Fig. 3). " Could you please add stats to this?

[mcgregorian1]

In this case do you mean running an anova on Rt ~ sp all together as well as per drought year, and then adding all four sets of grouping labels?

[teixeirak]

Since the plot just shows the individual droughts, we wouldn't show the grouping labels for droughts combined.

[mcgregorian1]

Ok so I'll do something similar to this and color code the groupings

[teixeirak]

Right. Basically the plot you have, with corresponding color-coded letters above each box.

[mcgregorian1]

This is saved as Figure 3

[mcgregorian1]

I'll also update the description in the results like you mentioned.

[mcgregorian1]

The text in the results on this figure currently reads, "Drought resistance also varied across species, overall and in each drought year (Fig. 3). " Could you please add stats to this?

@teixeirak currently the text reads "The development of tree-ring chronologies for the twelve most dominant tree species at our site [@helcoski_growing_2019; @bourg_initial_2013] gave us the sample size to compare historical drought responses across species (Fig. 3) and associated traits at a single site [see also @elliott_forest_2015]. "

Did you still want me to add something here?

[teixeirak]

Figure looks awesome; thanks!

[teixeirak]

@teixeirak currently the text reads "The development of tree-ring chronologies for the twelve most dominant tree species at our site [@helcoski_growing_2019; @bourg_initial_2013] gave us the sample size to compare historical drought responses across species (Fig. 3) and associated traits at a single site [see also @elliott_forest_2015]. "

Did you still want me to add something here?

You're looking in the discussion section. The sentence I quoted should be as quoted (or close) in the results.

[mcgregorian1]

Ah, ok. I searched "Fig. 3" in the doc but it didn't show up. I'll check again

[mcgregorian1]

@teixeirak am I good to push changes soon?

[teixeirak]

Yes, anytime. (Note that pushing would never mess things up, but working on it simultaneously could create conflicted copies that are a pain to resolve. I'm not working on it now.

[mcgregorian1]

Ok!

Also does this sound ok?

"Drought resistance also varied across species, overall and in each drought year (Fig. 3). Significant differences in $Rt$ across species were most abundant in 1966 with a total of seven distinct groupings, while 1977 had four and 1999 had two."

[teixeirak]

Sounds great! But maybe change "abundant" to "pronounced".

[mcgregorian1]

Cool it's updated. I'm going to get a little packing done and then focus on the references for most of tonight unless you have something more pressing (I think I've addressed the other stuff?).