Relation with Core Criterion

[EmidioStani]

Currently Public Service class is connected with Criterion Requirement via the hasCriterion relation.

The relation or the definition is a bit misleading:

1) As in Core Criterion and Evidence, there is already a Criterion class, the current relation "hasCriterion" in CPSV-AP would be better changed in "hasCriterionRequirement" (as it points to CriterionRequirement) however in Core Criterion and Evidence there exist already such relation where the domain is cv:RequirementGroup.

Therefore it could be better to point to a RequirementGroup which contains one or more criterions requirements.

2) In the current definition of the relation it is written:

Cardinality [0..n]. Links a Public Service to a class that describes the criteria for needing or using the service, such as residency in a given location, being over a certain age etc. The Criterion class is defined in the Core Criterion and Core Evidence Vocabulary."@en ;

There is a mention to the Criterion class which is not the range of the relation.

[brechtvdv]

I believe public services need to point to Criterion instead of CriterionRequirement so CPSV-AP and CCCEV are consistent. If there is the need to have a direct link from a public service to a requirement (for the sake of simplicity), this relation needs to be defined in CCCEV with the domain as reusable as possible

[kareljanr]

Based on the comments above I propose that the Public Service class points to Criterion and not Criterion Requirement.

For information: Definitions The Criterion class represents the rule or principle used to judge, evaluate or assess something. The Criterion class has the properties described below.

Criterion requirement group is the set of requirements that must be fulfilled together to validate a criterion.

A Criterion can be expressed as a set of requirements where every requirement must be valid. A Criterion requirement is an atomic requirement. This can be better explained with the examples in section 6.1, where the criterion is "to be eligible to enter into the cinema to watch a movie", and there are several options to meet this criterion. One option has two Criterion requirements:

• Holding a ticket
• Being older than eighteen Some criteria can be expressed with several atomic requirements. A Criterion requirement can specify the expected value that the Criterion response has to contain, or a range of threshold values within which the Criterion response has to fit in.

[NathanGhesq]

In CPSV-AP 3.0, the 'Criterion Requirement' has been changed to 'Requirement'. The Public Service class points to Requirement via the holdsRequirement relation.