search

SMPTE / rdd52

Other
6 stars 0 forks source link

6.2.1 : Territory 001 #13

Open JBoisseau-ByDeluxe opened 2 weeks ago

JBoisseau-ByDeluxe commented 2 weeks ago

rdd52 section 6.2.1 : "Language and Territory elements and attribute code values for XML documents shall conform to IETF RFC 5646"

st429-16 section 5.4.2.3 : "the value of the ReleaseTerritory shall be a valid region subtag found in the Language Subtag Registry specified in IETF RFC 5646. For generic international versions, the code 001 shall be used."

By reading this, a CPL with 001 as ReleaseTerritory does comply with st429-16 but not RDD52.

I think the intention of RDD52 wasn't to disallow the use of 001, and then the rule must be adjusted

palemieux commented 1 week ago

What is the rationale for closing the issue?

JBoisseau-ByDeluxe commented 1 week ago

Sorry, it was a misunderstanding of RFC5646, 001 is a valid RFC5646 territory code.