search

SMPTE / st430-1

Other
0 stars 0 forks source link

conflict between normative prose and normative schema #3

Open msheby opened 5 years ago

msheby commented 5 years ago

The schema in annex B is not as restrictive as the prose it describes (cf. sections 5.1 and 6.2). The annex's prefix ensures that the prose takes precedence and so this isn't intrinsically a bug.

That said, one could create an additional schema file that restricts the ETM as used by the KDM. This would allow for a more accurate representation of the prose within the constraints of an XML schema. This is analogous to https://github.com/SMPTE/st430-3/issues/1.

Alternatively: make the schema informative.

msheby commented 4 years ago

kdm-20xx.zip

msheby commented 4 years ago

etm_for_kdm.zip

palemieux commented 2 years ago

There is no conflict per se since the main prose (which is stricter) takes precedence of Annex B (which is looser).

I recommend deferring this until the next edition.