search

SSWConsulting / PointBank

Bringing high interest rates to boring tasks
1 stars 0 forks source link

Not convinced it will solve the employer problem. #7

Open tiagov8 opened 5 years ago

tiagov8 commented 5 years ago

I can see the employee problem solved - more incentive to do the tasks. But not the employer - the time to build/maintain this app will be significant compared to the benefit.

StevenA89 commented 5 years ago

This in my opinion is a waste of time. I do not see it adding value.

wicksipedia commented 5 years ago

@tiagov8 👍 it does look like extra admin to make it worthwhile I feel like there isn't enough benefit to make me want to use it

isonaj commented 5 years ago

Seems like a lot of overhead to produce a data stream that already exists.

isonaj commented 5 years ago

I'm also not sure how this app would help the employer know whether to prioritise standup desks or fingerprint scanners for the door.

camillars commented 5 years ago

I felt like it's going to take a lot of time to build this app comparing it to the benefit. +1 with all above.

kikibianc commented 5 years ago

I have seen systems like this used on other companies (much bigger companies), and the results were quite good. However, the rewards were much better as well - accumulating points gave you many more benefits:

The idea is good, but it needs to be well implemented and have worthy rewards.

LiamElliott-au commented 5 years ago

I see this as a platform that, yes, will incur extra overhead to get up and running, but is also very scale able.

PatrickZhao1989 commented 5 years ago

Good side of this application is that it could potentially save a lot of admin's time to create, distribute and chase for the questionnaires. It also in some degree encourages employee to complete some task. Downside is that it still does not have a solution when an employee just does not have time to complete the task even the task has good rewards in which case the employer has to chase.

hoangphan84 commented 5 years ago

I agree that this will add a lot of overheads to setup and maintain to the employer, that will make them less willing to invest in this product.

calumjs commented 5 years ago

@tiagov8 (emphasis mine)

I can see the employee problem solved - more incentive to do the tasks. But not the employer - the time to build/maintain this app will be significant compared to the benefit.

Keep in mind when evaluating the time taken that we should separate SSW as developers and SSW as users...an app that takes a lot of dev time but little admin time for users could still be beneficial to the users (but maybe still not worthwhile for us to invest the dev time in creating it).

@kikibianc

I have seen systems like this used on other companies (much bigger companies), and the results were quite good. However, the rewards were much better as well - accumulating points gave you many more benefits:

  • More leave time;
  • Free meals;
  • If you are on the top of the leaderboards for x amount of time, you win a trip to somewhere;
  • Even more money at the end of the month - I saw a particular company that you could convert the points to money after some time.

The idea is good, but it needs to be well implemented and have worthy rewards.

See #6

christoment commented 5 years ago

I also agree that although this could add some value for us, I'm not sure that we will have a good return compared to the time invested (dev time wise).

I can see the value for the company such as SSW where we have a weekly task, but I have a hard time seeing the business opportunity for this kind of app, as not many companies have a regular questionnaire (correct me if I'm wrong though).