search

ST-Apps / PoGo-UWP

UWP Client for Pokemon Go
831 stars 340 forks source link

Tranfer Complete Message #1331

Open collinTHEbrewer opened 8 years ago

collinTHEbrewer commented 8 years ago

Device info

Transfer pokemon to professor. After the newly stylized transfer dialog pops up, confirm the transfer.

Actual behavior

The confirmation dialog that appears is the default Windows style.

Expected behavior

Should be the new Pokemon Go stylized dialog.

Other information

swisszeni commented 8 years ago

Official App uses total different style for transfer confirmation. Will change directly to the right one and not PoGo Message Dialog.

collinTHEbrewer commented 8 years ago

It doesn't bother me that it isn't exactly the same as the official app, but I thought it should be consistent.

ArnoudBM commented 8 years ago

The modal popup message must be confirmed by clicking the [Close] button. In the official app, the confirmation disappears by itself. That would be an improvement. But I'm not sure the styled dialog supports this behavior.

swisszeni commented 8 years ago

That's why I said we won't use the styled dialog at all but use something that is more like the official app. But needs some more days till this is finished (has some more to it than just the text in a small rectangle), stay tuned.

somederp123 commented 8 years ago

transferring pokemon is lots of clicking work which is terrible in my opinion from UI designer's and even more users perspective, don't you guys agree?

it's a single task for transfer and you need x clicks:

(0. select pokemon)

  1. you have to click the right option circle on pokemon screen to call the new menu
  2. click transfer button
  3. confirm transfer with "yes"
  4. click away the "pokemon transferred" message

i know it's almost similar on the real app, but this doesn't mean PoGo has to be a clicking mess as bad as official app aswell.

in previous version the transfer button was on bottom of pokemon screen which was little more convenient.

Suggestions -> make it on bottom again additionally create settings menu make it optional wether to show a transfer confirmation message or not. *do not require the successful transfer message to be clicked, instead fade it out after like 1-2 seconds.

this surely would greatly improve the user experience, especially if you have to transfer lots of pokemon. this would result in 1 click at best instead of the 4 clicks needed right now.

New: transfer 10 pokemon->possible 20 clicks to -> select & transfer immediately Now: select, menu, transfer, confirm, notice x 10 -> 50 clicks...

that was only 10 pokemon, and most ppl have way more to transfer. guess that says it all.

robertmclaws commented 8 years ago

We're trying to make the app as close to official as possible, warts and all. Yes, the user experience is not ideal. But we'll do our best to at least make it look good, even if that means too many clicks.