search

SWE-574-GROUP-1 / SWE574-GROUP-1

This repository contains term project of 'Software Development as a Team' class in Bogazici University.
MIT License
1 stars 0 forks source link

Finalize Requirements #31

Closed damlaalkan closed 1 year ago

damlaalkan commented 1 year ago

The requirements for Posts, Spaces, Badges, Recommendations and Tags had finalized and documented in Wiki Page.

https://github.com/SWE-574-GROUP-1/SWE574-GROUP-1/wiki/%F0%9F%94%8D-2.-Mockup-&-Requirements-&-User-Stories

uskudarli commented 1 year ago

Some quick feedback.

The coverage is pretty good. Alas, there are some issues that I will summarize below.

The mockups:

  1. are pretty decent.
  2. Should give ID and title to each mockup
  3. The annotation could be described a bit better to illustrate the nature of how annotations would be made
  4. The semantic tags are not clear.

The recommendations:

  1. You have forgotten to give unique ID s for each recommendation. You still have bullet points.
  2. You have specified using to conventions (should format as well as user stories a la agile). This leads to overlapping requirements. Pick one and specify them consistently.
  3. The semantic tags are not clearly articulated. This: user shall be able to crate two different type of tags a informative and Wikidata is not specific enough and I can already see that it is not correct.
  4. Spaces: The user shall be able to create a space in the system. is not specific enough. You have some requirements that seem to be related. You can make them sub-level requirements so that all requirements related to the space creation are clearly and unambiguously defined.

(keep (4) in mind to revise similar requirements. ) As an example: it should be clear what information is needed to create spaces.

Please revise and inform me when it is done. @damlaalkan you (or your team) can re-assign to related parties as you see filt.

Fluentum commented 1 year ago

Requirements finalized and agreed with Suzan Hoca.