search

SabakiHQ / Sabaki

An elegant Go board and SGF editor for a more civilized age.
https://sabaki.yichuanshen.de/
MIT License
2.4k stars 375 forks source link

Every of GTPs for zen7 doesn't play in new sabaki! #643

Closed ak47ak50 closed 4 years ago

ak47ak50 commented 4 years ago

In 0.43,I have many GTPs for Zen7 can play normally. But in new 0.5, every of GTPs can't run. Does GTP in Sabaki 0.5 changed?

yishn commented 4 years ago

No. What is the error message?

ak47ak50 commented 4 years ago
  1. Load correct. 
    ZenGTP> name 
= Zen7
ZenGTP> version 
= 0.4
ZenGTP> protocol_version 
= 2
ZenGTP> list_commands 
= name
version
quit
known_command
list_commands
quit
boardsize
clear_board
komi
play
genmove
showboard
undo
pass
genmove
protocol_version
strength
maxtime
rotate
zen-analyze
loadsgf
printsgf
savesgf
time_settings
lz-analyze
time_left
set_free_handicap
final_score
analyze
go
auto
policy
territory
gogui-analyze_commands
sabaki-genmovelog
sabaki-flat

Starting Zen7... E:\zen7GTP/Zen.dll load ok Zen Initialize ok(59113473) Threads: 4 BoardSize: 19 Komi: 7.5 Resign: 10.0% Strength: 1000000 (counts, NN eval) MaxSim: 1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search) MaxTime: 30.0 PnLevel: 3 PnWeight: 1.00 VnMixRate: 0.75 ThinkInterval: 0.10 PrintInterval: 300.00

  1. But when genmove, it passed(see in Game Tree panel). ??? pass
ak47ak50 commented 4 years ago

3.Do I send the GTP to you?

yishn commented 4 years ago

Looking at the screenshot, it seems the engine is sending an empty response when asked for genmove B.

Can you please activate GTP logging in 'Preferences' > 'Engines', do this again, and send me the generated log file of GTP commands?

jun63cn commented 4 years ago 
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.379]     (in) : name
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.384]     (in) : version
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.386]     (in) : protocol_version
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.387]     (in) : list_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.388]   (meta) : Engine Started
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.425]    (err) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.425]    (err) : Starting Zen7...
[2020-03-13 20:52:18.442]    (err) : F:\Ѹ������\Zen�ر��\zen7/Zen.dll load ok
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.631]    (err) : Zen Initialize ok(42582017)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : Threads:   6
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : BoardSize: 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.632]    (err) : Komi:      7.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : Resign:    10.0%
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : Strength:  10000 (counts, NN eval)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.633]    (err) : MaxSim:    1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search)
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : MaxTime:   1000000000.0
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : PnLevel:   3
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.634]    (err) : PnWeight:  1.00
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : VnMixRate: 0.75
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : ThinkInterval:    0.10
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : PrintInterval:  300.00
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.635]    (err) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.648]    (out) : = Zen7
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.648]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : = 0.4
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.649]    (out) : = 2
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : = name
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.650]    (out) : version
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : known_command
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : list_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.651]    (out) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : boardsize
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : clear_board
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : komi
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : play
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : genmove
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.652]    (out) : showboard
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : undo
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : pass
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : genmove
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.653]    (out) : protocol_version
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : strength
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : maxtime
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : rotate
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : zen-analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : loadsgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.654]    (out) : printsgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : savesgf
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : time_settings
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : lz-analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : time_left
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : set_free_handicap
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.655]    (out) : final_score
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : analyze
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : go
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : auto
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : policy
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : territory
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : gogui-analyze_commands
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.656]    (out) : sabaki-genmovelog
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.657]    (out) : sabaki-flat
[2020-03-13 20:52:19.657]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.048]     (in) : komi 6.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.069]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.070]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.089]     (in) : boardsize 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.108]    (err) : Komi: 7.5 -> 6.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.109]    (err) : BoardSize: 19 -> 19
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.109]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.110]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.120]     (in) : clear_board
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.135]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.135]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.144]     (in) : genmove B
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.159]    (out) : = 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.160]    (out) : 
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.198]    (err) : * genmove for black...
[2020-03-13 20:52:29.199]    (err) :    Synchronize -> 1 (0.00s)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.285]    (err) :    Sequence:   Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 R10 Q3 R13 
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Winning:    48.9%
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Count:      1606
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Playout:    1905
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Time:       5.12s
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Games/s:    371.78
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.286]    (err) :    Nodes:      12810
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.299]    (err) :    Synchronize -> 12810 (0.01s)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.358]    (err) : Zen7-0.4 B No.   1 5.2s Q16 1606 48.87% Stop by Zen
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.359]    (err) : Q16  ->     1606, 48.87%, Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 R10 Q3 R13 
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.360]    (err) : R16  ->      264, 49.97%, R16 D16 Q3 D4 F17 C14
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.361]    (err) : K16  ->        5, 21.22%, K16
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.362]    (err) : level result(terr,area)
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.580]    (err) :     0   92.5   93.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.587]    (err) :   100  -14.5  -13.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.588]    (err) :   200   -4.5   -3.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.588]    (err) :   300   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   400   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   500   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.589]    (err) :   600   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   700   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   800   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.590]    (err) :   900   -6.5   -5.5
[2020-03-13 20:52:34.591]    (err) : W+5.5
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.423]     (in) : quit
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.477]   (meta) : Connection Failed
[2020-03-13 20:53:23.491]   (meta) : Engine Stopped
yishn commented 4 years ago

Seems like Zen is sending a wrong response at genmove B. Can you try executing your engine on the command line and sending genmove B to see what happens?

jun63cn commented 4 years ago 
Microsoft Windows [版本 6.1.7601]
版权所有 (c) 2009 Microsoft Corporation。保留所有权利。

C:\Users\Administrator>d:

D:\>cd zen7

D:\zen7>zengtp

Starting Zen7...
D:\zen7/Zen.dll load ok
Zen Initialize ok(41992193)
Threads:   4
BoardSize: 19
Komi:      7.5
Resign:    10.0%
Strength:  10000 (counts, NN eval)
MaxSim:    1000000000 (playouts, MCTS search)
MaxTime:   1000000000.0
PnLevel:   3
PnWeight:  1.00
VnMixRate: 0.75
ThinkInterval:    0.10
PrintInterval:  300.00

genmove b
* genmove for black...
   Synchronize -> 1 (0.00s)
   Sequence:   Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 P6 Q3 P4
   Winning:    47.9%
   Count:      1421
   Playout:    1803
   Time:       5.34s
   Games/s:    337.325
   Nodes:      11363
   Synchronize -> 11363 (0.05s)
Zen7-0.4 B No.   1 5.5s Q16 1421 47.89% Stop by Zen
Q16  ->     1421, 47.89%, Q16 D16 R4 D3 C5 P3 M4 P6 Q3 P4
R16  ->      352, 48.34%, R16 D16 Q3 D4 F17
level result(terr,area)
    0   91.5   92.5
  100  -15.5  -14.5
  200   -5.5   -4.5
  300   -7.5   -6.5
  400   -7.5   -6.5
  500   -7.5   -6.5
  600   -7.5   -6.5
  700   -7.5   -6.5
  800   -7.5   -6.5
  900   -7.5   -6.5
W+6.5
= Q16
yishn commented 4 years ago

For completion's sake, please send all commands to the engine that Sabaki is sending.

rooklift commented 4 years ago

Just in case, can you also check any difference between genmove b and genmove B

yishn commented 4 years ago

I had a hunch what might be the problem here, so I pushed a potential fix. Can you please try to build Sabaki from master and see if you still experience the issue?

jun63cn commented 4 years ago

It's works well now . Thanks You! UPYY`QNU~X}1ZUJS{7 4U@E