[Problem] MPF Crash with AOE III - Githubissues

SabreTools / MPF

Redumper/Aaru/DiscImageCreator GUI in C#

GNU General Public License v3.0

400 stars 35 forks source link

[Problem] MPF Crash with AOE III #695

Closed eingrossfilou closed 2 months ago

eingrossfilou commented 2 months ago

Before You Submit

Remember to try the latest WIP build to see if the issue has already been addressed.

-> No artifact newer than the stable version available

Is it copy protection related? If so, report the issue here instead.

Maybe (there is a typo in the template -> hhttps)

Version What version are you using?

[x] Stable release (version 3.17)
[ ] WIP release (version here) -> No artifact newer than the stable version available

Build What runtime version are you using?

[x] .NET 8.0 running on Windows 10

Describe the issue MPF unexpectedly quit when search for protection in disc file.

I observe in the past that this step copies the scanned file in MPF directory. Maybe there is a collision between a file on CD and files in MPF directory. Even if it is not the case, I think it is a bad practice.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

Put AOE III CD 1 in drive
Dump with default parameters (Either DIC or redumper)

Expected behavior Finish protection scanning and ask for disc information

Screenshots It just quit

Additional context

Nothing really informative in event manager apart log the crash dotnet crash

Maybe not related, but older version of MPF that were working few weeks ago crash at startup. Event manager indicates an exception with OpenClipboard:

Exception Info: System.Runtime.InteropServices.COMException (0x800401D0): Échec de OpenClipboard (0x800401D0 (CLIPBRD_E_CANT_OPEN))

Look like an update of dotnet breaks some things

mnadareski commented 2 months ago

Maybe not related, but older version of MPF that were working few weeks ago crash at startup. Event manager indicates an exception with OpenClipboard

Unrelated.

mnadareski commented 2 months ago

Both of you should try the latest WIP here: https://github.com/SabreTools/MPF/releases/tag/rolling. Not every file will get a perfect scan since some executables are obfuscated, but it should not crash the entire dump.

CookiePLMonster commented 2 months ago

Not every file will get a perfect scan since some executables are obfuscated, but it should not crash the entire dump.

I posted the test results of the latest rolling BOS release on Discord, as it was requested there.

mnadareski commented 2 months ago

It appears as though it's a standard obfuscated file, especially with the presence of the repeated "expected X got Y" messages. Those usually indicate data that has been deliberately messed with. I'm glad it did not crash. This particular issue is not unique to recent versions of BOS as every executable/library, obfuscated or not, is treated the same and has been for a long time.

More samples of these obfuscated executables are needed to try to avoid the glut of messages, but that particular part of the issue is not likely to change for a while.

mnadareski commented 2 months ago

The original issue of crashing does appear to have been fixed, though. That was an unfortunate issue stemming from libraries down the chain, not even BOS itself. If there are any more issues with crashing with the latest MPF build as linked in an above comment, then please report as such.

mnadareski commented 2 months ago

Can either of you confirm if this issue is still happening? I believe that this has been accounted for with the various sets of fixes that have gone into the last release.

eingrossfilou commented 2 months ago

Copy protection scan complete (and dump) ends successfully bu using
MPF_net8.0-windows_win-x64_debug.zip built from commit b4d47aea37b2eb8a5141801267f4727e472f35b4 with AOE III CD1