SaitoTech / saito-lite-rust

a version of the Saito-Lite client written for compatibility with the Saito Rust client and binary data format
24 stars 28 forks source link

Settlers Graphics #2625

Open arpee opened 1 month ago

arpee commented 1 month ago

Needed:

General

Bandit related

Icons

Misc

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

Dice Icon:

Image Image Image Image Image Image

Action Icon:

Image

Bank Icon:

Image

Buid Icon:

Image

Score Icon:

Image

Play & Pause Icons:

Image Image

Settlers principal background: Image

Currently working on the robin, the bandit and the knight, trying new interesting compositions, with visual history and interest

arpee commented 1 month ago

For the dice icon - we need a roll dice icon - not representations of the dice... (have you played the game?)

Also these are not really doing much to improve on what we had. We want icons that match the theme, look like things from that era. (play and pause possibly an exception).

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

For the dice icon - we need a roll dice icon - not representations of the dice... (have you played the game?)

Also these are not really doing much to improve on what we had. We want icons that match the theme, look like things from that era. (play and pause possibly an exception).

Yes sir I have played the game, just was thinking that is actually good to display the number with the dice and not just text, but I will make a "throw dice" icon instead.

I will explore some options to make it look more older, medieval icons instead, maybe adding some cuts like we have in the card so they I'll look less polished.

arpee commented 1 month ago

We are wanting to replace the roll dice icon we have not to match the other new icons.... I am worried you are not aware of were these icons will be used...

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

We are wanting to replace the roll dice icon we have not to match the other new icons.... I am worried you are not aware of were these icons will be used...

IMG_20241021_235003_045.jpg

The new icons will be used there, right? Except for the roll the dice one, that is displayed in our turn, but then new icons are fine? Should only work on the roll dice?

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

New dice roll icon: Image

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

Robin new set:

Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

Bandit new set:

Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

LawHe2o commented 1 month ago

Soldier / Knight artwork: Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

Arcade invite artwork:

Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

arpee commented 4 weeks ago

So, some feedback - we don't need to see so many versions of each graphic... none of these are particularly good.

We need you to work hard on an idea and present that idea with arguments about why it works. Then we can talk about it and make improvements.

First thoughts - these pictures all scream AI, which is mostly because they are clearly short prompts and the AI is doing most of the work. You need a story about what is in the picture. Also for the game the bandit should hopefully look like someone who might steal a sheep or some lumber, maybe he has a wagon? Robin hood, maybe there is a merry man or two in the vicinity helping?

We want the cards to have character and to make a story that the game tells.

arpee commented 4 weeks ago

We also still don't have a 'roll the dice' icon.

LawHe2o commented 4 weeks ago

New dice roll icon: Image

@arpee

Of course, I understand you, in reality the prompts that I have been using are quite long, in any case I can continue trying to offer a better narrative for the following propmts, generating 3 or 4 images for each one , and present them to you again in the shortest amount of time possible, BUT making sure that they are of better quality, the soldiers, knights, don't you think they are good either? And the invitation background? The dice icon is here Richard, does it work or do you have something else in mind, if you can send me a small example, it would help me a lot, also the dice icon is there, I attach it here as well:

Image

So, some feedback - we don't need to see so many versions of each graphic... none of these are particularly good.

We need you to work hard on an idea and present that idea with arguments about why it works. Then we can talk about it and make improvements.

First thoughts - these pictures all scream AI, which is mostly because they are clearly short prompts and the AI is doing most of the work. You need a story about what is in the picture. Also for the game the bandit should hopefully look like someone who might steal a sheep or some lumber, maybe he has a wagon? Robin hood, maybe there is a merry man or two in the vicinity helping?

We want the cards to have character and to make a story that the game tells.