search

SamanthaHindle / preprint_JournalClub

MIT License
23 stars 5 forks source link

Guide to discovering articles for PJC #11

Open chartgerink opened 7 years ago

chartgerink commented 7 years ago

This is a great idea, but for people starting with Preprints and seeing the value of reviewing them, it might be a good idea to provide some outline on how to discover preprints? Considering there are several repositories, some have already been published (defeating the PJC idea), it is important to have the right discovery process to find preprints relevant to the JC's interests.

It could be so simple as providing a resource list of preprint places, and as granular as curating several lists for various topics.

Maybe we can discuss here?

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

This is a great idea @chartgerink! Thank you so much for opening this issue. Hopefully once the Central Service that ASAPbio are initiating is launched next year, it will be easier to discover preprints but until then this list will be a wonderful resource. Thanks!

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

Great idea @chartgerink! Thank you!

chartgerink commented 7 years ago

So I found out about this application developed to discover preprints. It might be worthwhile checking out for discovery purposes: https://jhubiostatistics.shinyapps.io/papr/

I am looking whether I can contribute a database of OSF preprints into this so it is useful outside of biological sciences, but I think it's already usefule for ASAPbio (includes all bioRxiv abstracts)

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

@chartgerink thank you! I'm a bit unclear on the goal of the app. It says in for "rating" preprints more than finding them, but I guess the two things are connected.

edited: never mind, I just needed to read passed the profile page. :) Thank you!

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

Hi @chartgerink We have now developed a doc about preprints which includes a list of places to find preprints. If you have time, would you mind taking a look and let us know if it's thorough enough. Thanks for your help and suggestions. Best, Sam

chartgerink commented 7 years ago

@SamanthaHindle great! Maybe the SHARE preprint aggregate database might be worthwhile to add. (https://share.osf.io/discover?type=preprint). I figure you're only focusing on Bio? There are more fields that are active and this principle can be extended and then funneled down into subgroups. :)

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

Thank you @chartgerink for you comment. I think you are right, it would be good to expand to other fields, but bio is what we know best (and frankly what is most behind in terms of open). I think we can model (and test) the project around bio but make it so that other fields can do the same.

chartgerink commented 7 years ago

Yes of course :) I want to do a preprint journal club for psych, because there are many cool papers coming out on PsyArxiv (amongst others). Will build on this and contribute as I go. That's the beauty of open :)

beastlibrarian commented 6 years ago

Not sure if this is helpful: https://cshl.libguides.com/c.php?g=653424&p=4584615 Above guide includes link to journal preprint policies: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_academic_journals_by_preprint_policy And includes some examples of preprint servers.

more: https://libguides.usask.ca/c.php?g=16375&p=90316

SamanthaHindle commented 6 years ago

Hi @beastlibrarian These links are really helpful! Thank you! I've added to our doc about preprints.

Thanks so much! ❤️