search

SamanthaHindle / preprint_JournalClub

MIT License
23 stars 5 forks source link

Preprint Review Worksheet #5

Closed dasaderi closed 6 years ago

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

We want to create a template/worksheet to guide Preprint Journal Club leaders write reviews to send out to authors of the discussed preprints.

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

We created a draft document for the Review Guidelines/Feedback Worksheet. You can find it here. Please use the "Suggesting" mode to suggest edits, so we can see what changes have been made. It would be helpful if you log in to your Google account so we know who made what changes; this will allow us to send you a big THANK YOU!! Please write questions/comments here if you have any. Thanks!

amiefairs commented 7 years ago

I suggested some changed to your worksheet! Unfortunately I could only edit the link above and not even change it to suggesting, so I created a copy of the worksheet and suggested changes to that. The link is https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RmH0yhNtL0l75zYtwCELbaiRRwgyfXAVHu-SceMlyCM/edit?usp=sharing

I hope it is helpful! I really like the worksheet so far, I think it is very comprehensive. I remember somewhere on twitter seeing a 'guide to peer review for PhDs/ECRs' and I searched for it but couldn't find it... Maybe you guys have seen it? If you haven't, it might be useful in case there are areas you might want to address but have slipped your mine :)

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

Thank you so much Amie! Your comments are super helpful. I'm sorry you weren't able to change it to suggesting mode, but thank you for creating a new one.

Yes, I saw the twitter article too and was planning to find it today to add to the worksheet. If I manage to find it, I will share the link here.

Thanks again for your help. I really appreciate it!

KirstieJane commented 7 years ago

Heya! I looooove this project ❤️

Here's the Publons Academy curriculum.

And here's a fantastic blog post by Duncan Astle & Sue Fletcher-Watson: http://www.dart.ed.ac.uk/try-peer-review/

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

Thanks you soooooo much Kirstie! These resources are awesome...and thanks for our chat about this!

KirstieJane commented 7 years ago

Heya - If this is useful here's a peer review I wrote for F1000: https://f1000research.com/articles/5-1903/v1

The point of sharing this is to show off my template: synopsis, compliments then concerns/suggestions.

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

Here's a great list of questions that we can incorporate into the worksheet from the Publons Academy site: https://publons.com/blog/peer-review-essentials-for-the-beginning-peer/ by Elisabeth Bik

Thanks for the recommendation @KirstieJane! 🥇

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

Thank you so much @KirstieJane and @amiefairs! You girls rock!

chartgerink commented 7 years ago

Just added a few suggestions in the GDoc! :dango:

dasaderi commented 7 years ago

@chartgerink Thanks! I'll check now.

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

The updated review worksheet can be found here. Thanks!

SamanthaHindle commented 7 years ago

Hey @KirstieJane. I added your review to a Google drive folder we have created with example reviews. I hope that's ok. Let me know if not. I hope you are well! Thanks, Sam