ControlGUI sends mdi data to serial, board serial led indicates data comes but the floppy motor doesn't move

stilyan commented 3 months ago

System is Win10 Using Moppy 2.0 Tried Uno and Nano (chinese clones) to the same result On startup or board reset the floppy indicates with a tone Set baud rate 9600 and picked correct COM (confirmed via hardware manager) In the upper right corner there is no indication that board is picked by the GUI software When mdi starts the led of serial on board starts blinking Nothing on the floppy , no movement, nothing

When using old Moppy (classic) INO on the board + the GUI 2.0 Again in upper right corner empty but the floppy motor starts moving , however , no melody , just some weird movements back and forth

stilyan commented 3 months ago

Also tried testing drives by shorting pins as per guide video , motor moves back-forth indicating no hardware errors in drives

Another think I tried is connecting two drives to pins 1,2,3,4 and only one of the drives work (with old Moppy(classic) INO + GUI 2.0) , the second doesn't move On board reset however, both drives make the little 'tone'.

Sammy1Am commented 3 months ago

I don't think you'll be able to successfully use the MoppyClassic embedded code with the 2.0 GUI. Please stick to using the newer embedded code as well and let me know what happens.

Also, just want to confirm that "pins 1,2,3,4" means 2,3,4,5 (since 0 and 1 are COM pins)

On Tue, Mar 19, 2024, 09:29 Stilyan Georgiev @.***> wrote:

Also tried testing drives by shorting pins as per guide video , motor moves back-forth indicating no hardware errors in drives

Another think I tried is connecting two drives to pins 1,2,3,4 and only one of the drives work (with old Moppy(classic) INO + GUI 2.0) , the second doesn't move On board reset however, both drives make the little 'tone'.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/Sammy1Am/Moppy2/issues/206#issuecomment-2007630768, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AADSF6BZXR6MHGDXL6FBH4LYZBRU3AVCNFSM6AAAAABE546HTGVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDAMBXGYZTANZWHA . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>

stilyan commented 3 months ago

Using the classic INO on the board with GUI 2.0 was just an experiment, to see if I would get something out of it.

Also, just want to confirm that "pins 1,2,3,4" means 2,3,4,5 (since 0 and 1 are COM pins)

Correct, that was confusing statement from my side. Pins were 2,3 for floppy1 and 4,5 for floppy2.

The test setup currently is: Floppy 18-DIR, 20-STEP are on board pins 3, 2 12-SEL1 is grounded with 9-GND 17-GND goes to board GND pin Floppy is powered by an ATX power supply, all power pins are connected with the original floppy plug of the supply.

Moppy2.0 INO uploaded to the board, no errors. The avrdude while uploading determines the board signature 0x1e950f (probably m328p). As mentioned before, both boards (an Uno and Nano) are clones, non-originals. They use the CH340 driver.

Moppy2.0 GUI opens via .bat MDI file loaded, correct COM selected (checked via hardware manager), baud rate set to 9600.

When MDI starts, the serial led on board indicates activity but floppy motor doesn't move. The column at the upper right corner of the GUI doesn't show anything, its grayed.

Please let me know if more details are needed. I can also take pictures of the setup / screenshots of the GUI if necessary.

Sammy1Am commented 3 months ago

Thank you for the additional information, it sounds like things are pretty much set up correctly. A couple notes:

Arduino clones are fine, no worries there.
Pin connections seem fine.
With 2.0 INO, on reset, does the first (pins 2,3) drive play a little 4 note melody (as at 5:00 in this video?)
If the melody plays, the firmware and wiring are correct.
If the melody plays but the Arduino doesn't show up in the upper right of the GUI, there's some sort of COMs issue
The serial LED on the board will flash when data is sent to the board, even if there's no code on the board. So that's only really an indicator that your PC is trying to communicate, but doesn't mean it was successful.
If the melody doesn't play, something has gone wrong with the INO upload or configuration (or your wiring is wrong, but that seems unlikely at this point)

stilyan commented 3 months ago

With 2.0 INO, on reset, does the first (pins 2,3) drive play a little 4 note melody (as at 5:00 in this video?)

When reset button is pressed the floppy makes a little sound but doesn't move the motor forth and backwards as shown in the video. This behavior is the same with another floppy as well, doesn't seem to be hardware issue with the floppy itself. Made a video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Uey9J4fb30

When I'm playing around with the wires, shorting 18-DIR with 17-GND and tapping the 20-STEP the motor moves forward Then tapping 20-STEP with 17-GND moves it backwards. So the wiring and drive seem OK.

If the melody plays but the Arduino doesn't show up in the upper right of the GUI, there's some sort of COMs issue

Not sure if what I get on my setup considers as the 'melody', but since the board was hooked to the USB of a docking station, I tried the USB on the laptop itself. COM number changed when cable was switched but the same result, the GUI didn't show the board.

stilyan commented 3 months ago

Managed to get the motor moving with simple piece looking like so void loop() {

digitalWrite(dir, LOW);
for (int i=0; i<= 5; i++) {
digitalWrite(step,HIGH);
delay(1000);
digitalWrite(step,LOW);
}
delay(3000);
digitalWrite(dir, HIGH);
repeat of the for...
}

where step = 2 ; dir = 3 (the corresponding pins)

the thing movies back and forth with this so this tights down to the Moppy2.0 code

Sammy1Am commented 3 months ago

The video was very helpful, that is not the startup melody, so it seems that the 2.0 code is not uploaded or working correctly.

However the sound you are getting is probably the code resetting the drive, so there's some kind of Moppy code on there, but it might be the 1.0 code.

Double check that you're definitely using the latest 2.0 code, and then I guess maybe copy and paste the full output from the IDE upload process. Sometimes it will fail to upload but be very subtle about it.

stilyan commented 3 months ago

Got it working. The code was uploading, the startup melody didn't play because by default in config its defined false. I left the baud rate 57600 (as by default) instead of setting it 9600 in the GUI, checked the COM checkbox. Few seconds later on the upper right the device address showed up, I loaded MDI & it started running as if by miracle.

It is also worth mentioning to anyone reading this with similar problems - use the provided sample MDI files! Not all MDI files found on the net play for some reason.

Now is play time, need to hook the 4 more floppies I got and start searching for more to make an orchestra.

Thanks for your help and the work on this repo, really appreciate not having to write this up from scratch myself.

Sammy1Am commented 3 months ago

Glad you got it working!

The startup melody should default to true though: https://github.com/Sammy1Am/Moppy2/blob/master/Microcontroller/Moppy2-Arduino/src/MoppyConfig.h#L32

Maybe double check you're on the latest version, or let me know where you found it was disabled (maybe I've missed something)

Sammy1Am commented 3 months ago

Oh no! Just downloaded the zip file and it's false there! 😕 What?!

I'll have to fix that.

Sammy1Am / Moppy2

ControlGUI sends mdi data to serial, board serial led indicates data comes but the floppy motor doesn't move #206