SanchoGGP / ggp-base

The General Game Playing Base Package
8 stars 4 forks source link

Incorrect choice of lowest possible score because it was complete! #370

Open SteveDraper opened 9 years ago

SteveDraper commented 9 years ago

In a game of Escort-latch Breakthrough we uneccessarily suicided what should have been a win: http://www.ggp.org/view/tiltyard/matches/93115a1e4bf951fc969f9206a03f2b5706e65b3d/

Reason appears to be that all moves apart from the ones that immediately lose the king (which have a complete score of 50) have scores slightly over 50, BUT selection scores UNDER 50. This should be fairly easy to sort out.

The log snippet for the final move of Sancho's says it all (and should be sufficient to fairly easily address it):

2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move h 5 g 4 ) scores 52.20 (selectionScore 49.01, selection count 23328 [edge 23309, updates 23326.0], ref 85900160937)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.94, 48.06], visits 1899 [edge 1891, updates 1899.0], ref : 77310982372
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.01, 47.99], visits 1769 [edge 1759, updates 1769.0], ref : 51541964925
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [51.89, 48.11], visits 1994 [edge 1981, updates 1993.0], ref : 34362146243
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [52.08, 47.92], visits 1659 [edge 1657, updates 1659.0], ref : 42952579781
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.48, 48.52], visits 3403 [edge 3396, updates 3403.0], ref : 42952265755
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.19, 47.81], visits 1513 [edge 1506, updates 1513.0], ref : 25772157583
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.79, 48.21], visits 2249 [edge 2233, updates 2249.0], ref : 94490335809
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.65, 48.35], visits 3169 [edge 2664, updates 3169.0], ref : 111670798086
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.32, 47.68], visits 1352 [edge 1348, updates 1351.0], ref : 163209175736
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [54.74, 45.26], visits 486 [edge 474, updates 486.0], ref : 120259358896
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.91, 48.09], visits 1951 [edge 1946, updates 1951.0], ref : 137440121097
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.17, 46.83], visits 811 [edge 808, updates 811.0], ref : 103080955573
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [54.62, 45.38], visits 497 [edge 485, updates 497.0], ref : 60132112176
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [54.99, 44.99], visits 448 [edge 436, updates 448.0], ref : 77310911063
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.36, 46.64], visits 746 [edge 743, updates 746.0], ref : 42952637238
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move h 5 h 4 ) scores 52.25 (selectionScore 49.20, selection count 31307 [edge 31284, updates 31307.0], ref 103081280582)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.91, 48.09], visits 2429 [edge 2415, updates 2429.0], ref : 85901205512
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.34, 44.66], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 60131382665
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [55.65, 44.35], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 77310815073
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.54, 48.46], visits 6397 [edge 6391, updates 6397.0], ref : 103079902036
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [51.99, 48.01], visits 2961 [edge 2953, updates 2961.0], ref : 34362455760
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.93, 48.07], visits 3578 [edge 3171, updates 3578.0], ref : 51541899451
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.78, 47.22], visits 1412 [edge 1406, updates 1412.0], ref : 137439390124
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.72, 48.28], visits 4429 [edge 4419, updates 4429.0], ref : 34362665377
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.78, 46.22], visits 791 [edge 789, updates 791.0], ref : 94490351028
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.26, 47.74], visits 2147 [edge 2142, updates 2147.0], ref : 77311471272
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.14, 47.86], visits 2446 [edge 2437, updates 2446.0], ref : 42951450422
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.12, 47.88], visits 2500 [edge 2494, updates 2500.0], ref : 42952320725
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.29, 44.71], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 42951574059
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [52.98, 47.02], visits 1186 [edge 1183, updates 1186.0], ref : 111671189596
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move d 7 d 6 ) scores 52.31 (selectionScore 49.43, selection count 51785 [edge 51739, updates 51785.0], ref 85901508677)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.12, 47.88], visits 4337 [edge 4323, updates 4337.0], ref : 137439888343
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.96, 48.04], visits 5941 [edge 5930, updates 5941.0], ref : 94489920545
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.17, 47.83], visits 4037 [edge 4007, updates 4037.0], ref : 111669366246
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.18, 44.82], visits 536 [edge 524, updates 536.0], ref : 85900392650
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.88, 46.12], visits 889 [edge 884, updates 889.0], ref : 77309486201
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.42, 43.58], visits 389 [edge 377, updates 389.0], ref : 94491127328
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.87, 48.13], visits 7459 [edge 7445, updates 7459.0], ref : 77311107155
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.08, 47.92], visits 4678 [edge 4670, updates 4678.0], ref : 137438964495
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.76, 48.23], visits 10212 [edge 10203, updates 10212.0], ref : 128849444714
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.22, 47.78], visits 3667 [edge 3662, updates 3667.0], ref : 94490566956
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.32, 44.68], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 77310860734
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.64, 46.36], visits 991 [edge 986, updates 991.0], ref : 94490878597
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.11, 47.89], visits 5128 [edge 4450, updates 5128.0], ref : 94489935427
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.63, 47.37], visits 2153 [edge 2146, updates 2153.0], ref : 111670816056
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.91, 47.09], visits 1679 [edge 1675, updates 1679.0], ref : 171798701093
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move d 7 c 6 ) scores 52.19 (selectionScore 49.01, selection count 23631 [edge 23601, updates 23628.0], ref 60130873377)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.97, 48.03], visits 2094 [edge 2079, updates 2094.0], ref : 25772764913
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [54.82, 45.18], visits 485 [edge 473, updates 485.0], ref : 111669494941
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.76, 43.24], visits 308 [edge 296, updates 308.0], ref : 120259335642
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.69, 48.31], visits 2921 [edge 2910, updates 2918.0], ref : 146029097045
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.12, 47.88], visits 1815 [edge 1794, updates 1815.0], ref : 25772204487
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [51.69, 48.31], visits 2323 [edge 2313, updates 2323.0], ref : 120259162670
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.09, 47.91], visits 1850 [edge 1846, updates 1850.0], ref : 94491499493
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.15, 46.85], visits 877 [edge 873, updates 877.0], ref : 154619032772
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.50, 48.50], visits 3798 [edge 3791, updates 3798.0], ref : 60132337363
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.14, 47.86], visits 1757 [edge 1750, updates 1757.0], ref : 77311191976
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [57.38, 42.62], visits 260 [edge 248, updates 260.0], ref : 171798921476
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.01, 46.99], visits 950 [edge 946, updates 950.0], ref : 111670641072
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.60, 48.40], visits 3828 [edge 3252, updates 3828.0], ref : 146029126075
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.82, 47.18], visits 1062 [edge 1059, updates 1062.0], ref : 137440771000
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move f 3 f 2 ) scores 52.40 (selectionScore 49.70, selection count 168183 [edge 168132, updates 168171.0], ref 94491447069)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.59, 47.41], visits 6562 [edge 6541, updates 6562.0], ref : 120259119658
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [56.71, 43.29], visits 567 [edge 555, updates 567.0], ref : 42952166552
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.71, 43.29], visits 568 [edge 556, updates 568.0], ref : 94489493893
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [52.47, 47.53], visits 7976 [edge 7956, updates 7976.0], ref : 51541883268
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.58, 47.42], visits 6765 [edge 6751, updates 6765.0], ref : 60131656666
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.66, 47.34], visits 5694 [edge 5678, updates 5694.0], ref : 34361964887
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [54.83, 45.17], visits 1038 [edge 1034, updates 1038.0], ref : 60130489180
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.85, 48.15], visits 109223 [edge 109215, updates 109211.0], ref : 154619278878
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.63, 47.37], visits 5939 [edge 5931, updates 5939.0], ref : 103081241526
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.66, 47.34], visits 5956 [edge 5928, updates 5956.0], ref : 34362611235
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [56.74, 43.26], visits 546 [edge 534, updates 546.0], ref : 77310532005
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [54.14, 45.86], visits 1455 [edge 1451, updates 1455.0], ref : 60132493609
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.46, 47.54], visits 9130 [edge 8200, updates 9130.0], ref : 68720911825
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [53.46, 46.54], visits 2321 [edge 2309, updates 2321.0], ref : 34362566885
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.68, 47.32], visits 5552 [edge 5543, updates 5552.0], ref : 111671212452
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move f 3 g 2 ) scores 52.38 (selectionScore 49.65, selection count 123924 [edge 123862, updates 123920.0], ref 77311349038)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [52.32, 47.68], visits 9491 [edge 9456, updates 9491.0], ref : 77310563513
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.60, 47.40], visits 5450 [edge 5423, updates 5450.0], ref : 77310669568
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.55, 47.45], visits 5957 [edge 5943, updates 5957.0], ref : 34361968693
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.72, 44.28], visits 713 [edge 701, updates 713.0], ref : 85900288224
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.37, 47.63], visits 9476 [edge 8251, updates 9476.0], ref : 94490005284
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [53.10, 46.90], visits 2987 [edge 2974, updates 2987.0], ref : 60131100433
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.59, 47.41], visits 5566 [edge 5546, updates 5566.0], ref : 111669858200
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.50, 47.50], visits 6517 [edge 6473, updates 6517.0], ref : 77310932846
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [54.08, 45.92], visits 1436 [edge 1431, updates 1436.0], ref : 34362017342
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.74, 48.26], visits 63926 [edge 63882, updates 63922.0], ref : 180389102500
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.59, 47.41], visits 5503 [edge 5489, updates 5503.0], ref : 103080468217
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [57.70, 42.30], visits 422 [edge 410, updates 422.0], ref : 34362028653
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [56.81, 43.19], visits 519 [edge 507, updates 519.0], ref : 154619116214
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [54.89, 45.11], visits 960 [edge 956, updates 960.0], ref : 128849753764
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.49, 47.50], visits 6581 [edge 6481, updates 6581.0], ref : 25772201316
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move f 3 e 2 ) scores 52.37 (selectionScore 49.62, selection count 105287 [edge 105199, updates 105287.0], ref 34360950138)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [56.36, 43.64], visits 543 [edge 531, updates 543.0], ref : 94489911647
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.29, 43.71], visits 544 [edge 532, updates 544.0], ref : 42952134673
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.33, 47.67], visits 7035 [edge 7000, updates 7035.0], ref : 42952022529
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.30, 47.70], visits 8582 [edge 7572, updates 8582.0], ref : 120260175264
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.85, 47.15], visits 3239 [edge 3234, updates 3239.0], ref : 34362394940
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.97, 46.02], visits 1334 [edge 1331, updates 1334.0], ref : 146029004951
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [52.16, 47.84], visits 10400 [edge 10386, updates 10400.0], ref : 85901177228
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.45, 47.55], visits 5653 [edge 5637, updates 5653.0], ref : 120260638526
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.35, 47.65], visits 6741 [edge 6724, updates 6741.0], ref : 42952018494
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.29, 47.71], visits 7875 [edge 7860, updates 7875.0], ref : 103079717171
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.85, 48.15], visits 39804 [edge 39788, updates 39804.0], ref : 154619856593
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.45, 47.55], visits 5653 [edge 5643, updates 5653.0], ref : 171799044408
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [56.67, 43.33], visits 515 [edge 503, updates 515.0], ref : 146028900654
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.58, 46.42], visits 1712 [edge 1708, updates 1712.0], ref : 60131052164
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.36, 47.64], visits 6866 [edge 6837, updates 6866.0], ref : 42952209340
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move e 6 e 5 ) scores 50.00 (selectionScore 49.92, selection count 571 [edge 571, updates 0.0], ref 34361340856, complete [2])
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move e 6 f 5 ) scores 50.00 (selectionScore 49.92, selection count 571 [edge 571, updates 0.0], ref 34362409162, complete [2])
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move e 6 d 6 ) scores 50.00 (selectionScore 49.92, selection count 571 [edge 571, updates 0.0], ref 188978645276, complete [2])
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move e 6 f 6 ) scores 52.37 (selectionScore 49.64, selection count 119277 [edge 119236, updates 119276.0], ref 68721012179)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [53.12, 46.88], visits 2510 [edge 2501, updates 2510.0], ref : 111671093871
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [53.12, 46.88], visits 2522 [edge 2516, updates 2522.0], ref : 94491363726
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [53.74, 46.26], visits 1632 [edge 1624, updates 1632.0], ref : 68721042322
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [53.25, 46.75], visits 2421 [edge 2411, updates 2421.0], ref : 111671111249
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [53.16, 46.84], visits 3128 [edge 2404, updates 3128.0], ref : 34361986623
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [53.31, 46.69], visits 2623 [edge 2617, updates 2623.0], ref : 146029402852
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [53.38, 46.62], visits 2058 [edge 2050, updates 2058.0], ref : 120260846389
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.98, 47.02], visits 2826 [edge 2817, updates 2826.0], ref : 120259454337
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [53.11, 46.89], visits 2926 [edge 2920, updates 2926.0], ref : 128849664508
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.40, 46.60], visits 2056 [edge 2044, updates 2056.0], ref : 94489317697
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.59, 48.41], visits 88434 [edge 86359, updates 88433.0], ref : 42952252419
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [53.84, 46.16], visits 1499 [edge 1493, updates 1499.0], ref : 111671084856
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [56.12, 43.88], visits 607 [edge 595, updates 607.0], ref : 60130821773
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.65, 47.35], visits 4038 [edge 4001, updates 4038.0], ref : 103079461081
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.95, 47.05], visits 2926 [edge 2916, updates 2926.0], ref : 103081392924
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move e 6 d 5 ) scores 50.00 (selectionScore 49.92, selection count 571 [edge 571, updates 0.0], ref 68720895961, complete [2])
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move g 6 g 5 ) scores 52.18 (selectionScore 48.91, selection count 20491 [edge 20470, updates 20491.0], ref 34362617387)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.06, 47.94], visits 1450 [edge 1440, updates 1450.0], ref : 120260923233
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [51.91, 48.09], visits 1632 [edge 1626, updates 1632.0], ref : 154619281987
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.10, 44.90], visits 427 [edge 415, updates 427.0], ref : 77311569760
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [54.41, 45.59], visits 498 [edge 486, updates 498.0], ref : 34362620894
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.01, 47.99], visits 1497 [edge 1492, updates 1497.0], ref : 25772525819
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.94, 48.06], visits 1602 [edge 1591, updates 1602.0], ref : 94489403252
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.51, 48.49], visits 2514 [edge 2504, updates 2514.0], ref : 171798900204
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.20, 44.80], visits 515 [edge 503, updates 515.0], ref : 163209208194
2015-09-27 18:50:47,794 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [52.69, 47.31], visits 946 [edge 942, updates 946.0], ref : 85899730957
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.00, 48.00], visits 1938 [edge 1511, updates 1938.0], ref : 111669427210
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.20, 47.80], visits 1288 [edge 1285, updates 1288.0], ref : 85900423447
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.05, 47.94], visits 1459 [edge 1436, updates 1459.0], ref : 120259683603
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.09, 46.91], visits 787 [edge 783, updates 787.0], ref : 103079979812
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.38, 48.62], visits 2985 [edge 2980, updates 2985.0], ref : 163209128885
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.01, 47.99], visits 1504 [edge 1496, updates 1504.0], ref : 85900532225
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move g 6 f 5 ) scores 52.25 (selectionScore 49.19, selection count 30423 [edge 30406, updates 30416.0], ref 128849828408)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.29, 43.71], visits 385 [edge 372, updates 385.0], ref : 17182357111
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.26, 47.74], visits 1934 [edge 1929, updates 1933.0], ref : 180388723790
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [56.16, 43.84], visits 378 [edge 376, updates 378.0], ref : 85899973605
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.01, 47.99], visits 3176 [edge 2533, updates 3175.0], ref : 128849495674
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.48, 47.52], visits 1570 [edge 1567, updates 1570.0], ref : 120260780493
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.20, 46.80], visits 966 [edge 964, updates 966.0], ref : 51542417447
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.87, 48.13], visits 3064 [edge 3061, updates 3064.0], ref : 128850795479
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.86, 48.14], visits 3107 [edge 3089, updates 3107.0], ref : 137439049774
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.22, 47.78], visits 2007 [edge 1996, updates 2005.0], ref : 51542180961
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.94, 48.06], visits 2778 [edge 2774, updates 2778.0], ref : 120261191790
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.14, 47.86], visits 2174 [edge 2170, updates 2174.0], ref : 85900060467
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.56, 48.44], visits 5308 [edge 5302, updates 5306.0], ref : 60132185561
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [51.99, 48.01], visits 2596 [edge 2592, updates 2596.0], ref : 60132277381
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [54.84, 45.16], visits 537 [edge 525, updates 536.0], ref : 60131612303
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [52.87, 47.13], visits 1165 [edge 1163, updates 1165.0], ref : 77310629847
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move a 7 a 6 ) scores 52.25 (selectionScore 49.22, selection count 32028 [edge 31992, updates 32025.0], ref 17182650229)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.86, 48.14], visits 3279 [edge 3267, updates 3279.0], ref : 94491356015
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.78, 48.22], visits 3678 [edge 3660, updates 3678.0], ref : 51541596610
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.92, 47.08], visits 1168 [edge 1164, updates 1168.0], ref : 111670132530
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.37, 47.63], visits 1802 [edge 1790, updates 1802.0], ref : 128849958349
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.14, 47.86], visits 2276 [edge 2268, updates 2275.0], ref : 34361990208
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [54.66, 45.34], visits 560 [edge 548, updates 560.0], ref : 120259120387
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [55.84, 44.16], visits 417 [edge 405, updates 417.0], ref : 85900833713
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.97, 48.03], visits 2818 [edge 2798, updates 2817.0], ref : 94491303115
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.11, 47.89], visits 3152 [edge 2351, updates 3152.0], ref : 42952198502
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.92, 48.08], visits 2989 [edge 2983, updates 2988.0], ref : 103081098511
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.51, 44.49], visits 446 [edge 434, updates 446.0], ref : 51542403299
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.29, 46.71], visits 943 [edge 939, updates 943.0], ref : 77310841068
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.82, 46.18], visits 732 [edge 728, updates 732.0], ref : 94490857180
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.64, 48.36], visits 4717 [edge 4709, updates 4717.0], ref : 77311279981
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [51.73, 48.27], visits 3993 [edge 3983, updates 3993.0], ref : 25772249733
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move a 7 b 6 ) scores 52.27 (selectionScore 49.28, selection count 36171 [edge 36149, updates 36171.0], ref 154618919020)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.16, 44.84], visits 495 [edge 483, updates 495.0], ref : 77310293565
2015-09-27 18:50:47,795 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [56.07, 43.93], visits 401 [edge 389, updates 401.0], ref : 94490326551
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [51.89, 48.11], visits 3708 [edge 3697, updates 3708.0], ref : 68720376031
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.68, 47.32], visits 1565 [edge 1564, updates 1565.0], ref : 85901478516
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.79, 48.21], visits 4381 [edge 4374, updates 4381.0], ref : 51541938317
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.90, 48.10], visits 3532 [edge 3518, updates 3532.0], ref : 111670681725
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.83, 48.17], visits 4142 [edge 4135, updates 4142.0], ref : 85901547386
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.88, 46.12], visits 758 [edge 755, updates 758.0], ref : 85901490446
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.78, 48.22], visits 4486 [edge 4476, updates 4486.0], ref : 51542549465
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.29, 47.71], visits 2214 [edge 2205, updates 2214.0], ref : 137439890750
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.31, 44.69], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 137440134442
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.23, 46.77], visits 1066 [edge 1062, updates 1066.0], ref : 25772081118
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.80, 48.20], visits 4973 [edge 4313, updates 4973.0], ref : 25772233340
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.57, 47.43], visits 1710 [edge 1705, updates 1710.0], ref : 94491418757
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.02, 47.98], visits 3015 [edge 2992, updates 3015.0], ref : 137439432461
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move b 5 c 4 ) scores 52.04 (selectionScore 48.32, selection count 11961 [edge 11938, updates 11961.0], ref 103081147221)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [52.00, 48.00], visits 801 [edge 799, updates 801.0], ref : 120259122241
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [51.44, 48.56], visits 1142 [edge 1136, updates 1142.0], ref : 51542507804
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [51.81, 48.19], visits 897 [edge 888, updates 897.0], ref : 94489789158
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.57, 48.43], visits 1041 [edge 1034, updates 1041.0], ref : 42951927769
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [51.69, 48.31], visits 976 [edge 969, updates 976.0], ref : 60130706457
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [54.78, 45.22], visits 330 [edge 318, updates 330.0], ref : 34360913806
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [54.20, 45.80], visits 375 [edge 363, updates 375.0], ref : 68720163165
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.74, 48.26], visits 947 [edge 927, updates 947.0], ref : 60130741259
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.58, 48.42], visits 1034 [edge 1026, updates 1034.0], ref : 120259135648
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [52.86, 47.14], visits 554 [edge 551, updates 554.0], ref : 94491133354
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [53.15, 46.85], visits 502 [edge 490, updates 502.0], ref : 34362407297
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [52.11, 47.89], visits 775 [edge 772, updates 775.0], ref : 103080706584
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.86, 48.14], visits 871 [edge 862, updates 871.0], ref : 111669334037
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.80, 48.20], visits 1286 [edge 894, updates 1286.0], ref : 85901095088
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [51.74, 48.26], visits 932 [edge 931, updates 932.0], ref : 85900162310
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move b 5 b 4 ) scores 52.00 (selectionScore 48.15, selection count 10653 [edge 10634, updates 10650.0], ref 51542324322)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [51.61, 48.39], visits 932 [edge 924, updates 932.0], ref : 163209282082
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [51.54, 48.45], visits 970 [edge 962, updates 970.0], ref : 85900741042
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.70, 48.30], visits 879 [edge 875, updates 878.0], ref : 111669256020
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [52.97, 47.03], visits 523 [edge 511, updates 523.0], ref : 128850427010
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.75, 48.24], visits 859 [edge 848, updates 859.0], ref : 34362067476
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [53.67, 46.33], visits 419 [edge 407, updates 419.0], ref : 17182301803
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.88, 48.12], visits 1157 [edge 793, updates 1157.0], ref : 188979107427
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [51.52, 48.48], visits 980 [edge 978, updates 979.0], ref : 128849157315
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.52, 48.48], visits 988 [edge 977, updates 988.0], ref : 137439617853
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [52.75, 47.25], visits 542 [edge 539, updates 542.0], ref : 34362229688
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.32, 48.68], visits 1130 [edge 1124, updates 1129.0], ref : 128849344796
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [51.74, 48.24], visits 872 [edge 847, updates 872.0], ref : 180389064901
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [53.30, 46.70], visits 473 [edge 461, updates 473.0], ref : 77310739174
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.71, 46.29], visits 409 [edge 406, updates 409.0], ref : 111670620004
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move b 5 a 4 ) scores 52.22 (selectionScore 49.08, selection count 25550 [edge 25520, updates 25548.0], ref 42952624316)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.54, 48.46], visits 4023 [edge 4017, updates 4023.0], ref : 171798852262
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [51.75, 48.25], visits 2893 [edge 2887, updates 2893.0], ref : 120259347815
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 a 4 ) scores [52.55, 47.44], visits 1328 [edge 1327, updates 1328.0], ref : 51542230940
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [54.93, 45.07], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 94490140436
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.11, 47.89], visits 1902 [edge 1896, updates 1902.0], ref : 154618860664
2015-09-27 18:50:47,796 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.79, 48.21], visits 2764 [edge 2756, updates 2764.0], ref : 146029006910
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.03, 47.97], visits 2077 [edge 2063, updates 2076.0], ref : 103081370797
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.46, 46.54], visits 813 [edge 809, updates 813.0], ref : 42951976390
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.25, 47.75], visits 1707 [edge 1677, updates 1706.0], ref : 77311084685
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.73, 48.27], visits 2985 [edge 2971, updates 2985.0], ref : 103079334305
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [55.98, 44.02], visits 392 [edge 379, updates 392.0], ref : 51542410124
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [55.11, 44.89], visits 515 [edge 502, updates 515.0], ref : 68720755150
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.35, 46.65], visits 848 [edge 843, updates 848.0], ref : 120260868691
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.76, 48.24], visits 2927 [edge 2908, updates 2927.0], ref : 77309993925
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move f 4 g 3 ) scores 52.39 (selectionScore 49.70, selection count 181363 [edge 181363, updates 181363.0], ref 51540857190)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [55.99, 43.97], visits 664 [edge 651, updates 664.0], ref : 51542344953
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [57.02, 42.98], visits 511 [edge 499, updates 511.0], ref : 154619322715
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.56, 47.44], visits 6764 [edge 6749, updates 6764.0], ref : 51542429055
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [52.35, 47.65], visits 10498 [edge 10490, updates 10498.0], ref : 120260523668
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [54.12, 45.88], visits 1468 [edge 1464, updates 1468.0], ref : 60132222702
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.74, 47.26], visits 4983 [edge 4979, updates 4983.0], ref : 51541365960
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [52.55, 47.45], visits 6789 [edge 6784, updates 6789.0], ref : 25772712195
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.90, 48.10], visits 114680 [edge 114674, updates 114680.0], ref : 34362163353
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.48, 47.52], visits 7787 [edge 7780, updates 7787.0], ref : 68721229912
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [52.32, 47.68], visits 12541 [edge 11385, updates 12541.0], ref : 85901213994
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [53.05, 46.95], visits 3387 [edge 3384, updates 3387.0], ref : 51542399168
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [52.59, 47.41], visits 6376 [edge 6372, updates 6376.0], ref : 51542021982
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [57.15, 42.85], visits 514 [edge 502, updates 514.0], ref : 85899857348
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [54.84, 45.16], visits 1022 [edge 1017, updates 1022.0], ref : 77310992995
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [52.79, 47.21], visits 4627 [edge 4627, updates 4627.0], ref : 68721478597
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 INFO  TreeNode                       Move ( move f 4 e 3 ) scores 52.21 (selectionScore 49.07, selection count 25248 [edge 25248, updates 25225.0], ref 128850127293)
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 c 4 ) scores [51.46, 48.54], visits 3992 [edge 3992, updates 3990.0], ref : 60131912817
2015-09-27 18:50:47,797 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 d 6 ) scores [52.06, 47.94], visits 1891 [edge 1891, updates 1890.0], ref : 103081025543
2015-09-27 18:50:47,802 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 c 6 ) scores [51.68, 48.32], visits 2484 [edge 2484, updates 2482.0], ref : 51540747588
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move c 5 b 6 ) scores [51.92, 48.08], visits 2181 [edge 2181, updates 2177.0], ref : 94490273365
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 a 5 ) scores [51.95, 48.05], visits 2109 [edge 2109, updates 2109.0], ref : 42952331517
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move a 4 b 5 ) scores [52.71, 47.29], visits 1129 [edge 1129, updates 1128.0], ref : 103080321561
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 f 5 ) scores [53.85, 46.15], visits 645 [edge 645, updates 645.0], ref : 42951929665
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 h 4 ) scores [52.06, 47.94], visits 1878 [edge 1878, updates 1875.0], ref : 60131886462
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 3 g 4 ) scores [51.88, 48.12], visits 2281 [edge 2281, updates 2279.0], ref : 120260913938
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 e 5 ) scores [53.53, 46.47], visits 730 [edge 730, updates 730.0], ref : 51542236771
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move e 4 d 5 ) scores [54.05, 45.95], visits 599 [edge 599, updates 599.0], ref : 85900677176
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move b 3 b 4 ) scores [52.04, 47.96], visits 1926 [edge 1926, updates 1923.0], ref : 60132157896
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 d 5 ) scores [54.96, 45.04], visits 502 [edge 502, updates 500.0], ref : 171798698429
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move d 4 e 5 ) scores [53.36, 46.64], visits 1092 [edge 788, updates 1090.0], ref : 85900600925
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 DEBUG TreeNode                           Response ( move h 2 g 3 ) scores [51.95, 48.05], visits 2107 [edge 2107, updates 2106.0], ref : 60131653750
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 INFO  TreeNode                       1 level minimax result differed from best raw move: org.ggp.base.player.gamer.statemachine.sancho.TreeEdge@6d60794d
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 INFO  TreeNode                       Most likely path: ( move e 6 e 5 ), ( move a 4 a 5 ) | ( move e 5 d 4 ), ( move c 5 b 6 ) | ( move f 3 e 2 ), ( move h 3 g 4 ) | ( move g 6 f 5 )
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 INFO  FactorMoveChoiceInfo           Best move was ( move e 6 e 5 ), scoring 50.00
2015-09-27 18:50:47,803 INFO  MCTSTree                       Num nodes in use: 2577605
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  MCTSTree                       Num true rollouts added: 373225
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  MCTSTree                       Num terminal nodes revisited: 93270
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  MCTSTree                       Num incomplete nodes: 0
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  MCTSTree                       Num completely explored branches: 322725
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  MCTSTree                       Current observed rollout score range: [50, 100]
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 DEBUG FactorMoveChoiceInfo             Factor best move:          ( move e 6 e 5 )
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 DEBUG FactorMoveChoiceInfo             Factor best move value:    50.0
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 DEBUG FactorMoveChoiceInfo             Factor best move complete? true
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 DEBUG FactorMoveChoiceInfo             Factor no-op value:        100.0
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 DEBUG FactorMoveChoiceInfo             Factor no-op complete?     false
2015-09-27 18:50:47,807 INFO  Sancho                         Playing move: ( move e 6 e 5 )