SasaKaranovic / DIY_Eink_Gadget

Project source files for DIY Eink Gadget. Project video available at https://youtu.be/i01PoMj23bA
https://sasakaranovic.com/projects/diy-eink-gadget/
10 stars 0 forks source link

Is this project open source hardware and/or open source software? #1

Open abetusk opened 1 year ago

abetusk commented 1 year ago

From the YouTube video:

... as always the entire project is open source open hardware so you can easily make any changes or improvements ...

As of this writing, this project is, as far as I can tell, "closed source" (at least here in the US) since there is no indication about what license is that the project falls under. I don't see a LICENSE file for the project nor do I see license file headers in the source files. If I've missed these, my apologies.

"Open Source" has a generally accepted meaning of being able to use the digital artifacts for commercial purposes. The OSI and Wikipedia's entry on open-source licensing both articulate that commercial re-use is a (generally accepted) requirement of an "open source" license.

The Open Source Hardware Association articulates requirements of design files to meet their "open source" standards:

Open source hardware is hardware whose design is made publicly available so that anyone can study, modify, distribute, make, and sell the design or hardware based on that design.

Without licensing information about the various digital artifacts (BOM, schematic, Gerbers, source code, etc.), the default is for them to fall under copyright protection and are not allowed to be copied, modified or distributed without explicit consent.

Was the intent to make this project libre/free/open source software/hardware?

If so, could you indicate the license, either by providing a LICENSE file with the appropriate license or by putting a license preamble in each of the source files (preferably both).

If not, it might be good to clarify what the restrictions are to avoid confusion. For example, indicating that the source is available, rather than it being open source.

vazhnov commented 8 months ago

It would be great to see any popular open source license here!