search

SciKit-Surgery / scikit-surgerytutorial02

SciKit-Surgery Tutorial02 provides a tutorial on how to implement a simple algorithm using the SciKit-Surgery project's Python Template
http://scikit-surgerytutorial02.readthedocs.io/en/latest/?badge=latest
Other
1 stars 1 forks source link

Feedback from miccai educational challenge #13

Closed thompson318 closed 1 year ago

thompson318 commented 4 years ago

In GitLab by @StephenThompson on Oct 24, 2019, 15:56

REVIEWER 1

OVERALL SCORE Strong Accept

PLEASE RATE THE ACCURACY OF CONTENT 5

PLEASE RATE THE COMPREHENSIVENESS OF CONTENT 5

PLEASE RATE THE APPROPRIATE LEVEL (ACCESSIBLE TO NEW MASTERS AND PHD STUDENTS?) 5

PLEASE RATE THE RELEVANCE TO THE MICCAI COMMUNITY 5

PLEASE RATE THE CLARITY 5

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE STUDENT COMMUNITY 5

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY 5

HOW LIKELY WOULD YOU BE TO RECOMMEND THIS EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL TO A STUDENT WHO WAS INTERESTED IN THE TOPIC? 4

PLEASE LIST THE MAJOR STRENGTHS OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST) Step by step, with nice code formatting, screenshots, etc. would seem very reasonable to run through for someone of appropriate experience

PLEASE LIST ANY MAJOR WEAKNESSES OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST) while the content was well described, it wasn't immediately clear from the first page what exactly snappy "is" and the precise functionality it is intended to contribute. would suggest adding a bulleted list for both of those topics

SUGGESTIONS TO THE AUTHORS / OTHER FEEDBACK see weakness above

REVIEWER 2

OVERALL SCORE Weak Reject

PLEASE RATE THE ACCURACY OF CONTENT 4

PLEASE RATE THE COMPREHENSIVENESS OF CONTENT 4

PLEASE RATE THE APPROPRIATE LEVEL (ACCESSIBLE TO NEW MASTERS AND PHD STUDENTS?) 5

PLEASE RATE THE RELEVANCE TO THE MICCAI COMMUNITY 1

PLEASE RATE THE CLARITY 4

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE STUDENT COMMUNITY 3

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY 3

HOW LIKELY WOULD YOU BE TO RECOMMEND THIS EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL TO A STUDENT WHO WAS INTERESTED IN THE TOPIC? 4

PLEASE LIST THE MAJOR STRENGTHS OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST)

PLEASE LIST ANY MAJOR WEAKNESSES OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST) -It is useful for everybody but does not related specifically to The MICCAI audience.

SUGGESTIONS TO THE AUTHORS / OTHER FEEDBACK nan

thompson318 commented 4 years ago

In GitLab by @StephenThompson on Dec 18, 2019, 12:16

assigned to @StephenThompson

mxochicale commented 1 year ago

Hi @thompson318

Do you know where is the paper? Perhaps we can add it to discussion and close this issue?

thompson318 commented 1 year ago

I'm not sure what you mean by the paper. The feedback is in the first comment above. Is that what you mean?

mxochicale commented 1 year ago

Hi Steve, I was not really sure if the feedback came from an publication. So, feedback is useful but maybe outdated, so I will vote to close this one. Unless you want to keep such feedback somewhere in the repo rather than in an issue. Thanks, --Miguel