ScratchAddons / ScratchAddons

All-in-one browser extension for Scratch.
https://scratchaddons.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
719 stars 370 forks source link

Old studio layout addon doesn't make it 100% look like the 2.0 studio layout #7347

Open Waakul opened 7 months ago

Waakul commented 7 months ago

Why this would be helpful

It is supposed to make it look 100% like 2.0's studio layout but it doesnt.

My suggestion

Compare these two images and see the difference: image image Source of 2.0 layout image: https://web.archive.org/web/20201102201631/https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/14/projects/

Possible alternatives

No response

Additional context

No response

ghost commented 7 months ago

The only differences I can honestly see here are very small - Namely:

The first and third of those are unrelated to the layout itself. The UI is actually a bit more helpful, even if it's a bit weird with how big it is.

Layout is only the placement, not all of how the page (...well, specifically the studio modals and etc. appear in this case) appears visually. So, the addon does it's job like it needs to. It just returns the old layout, not transform the studio pages into exactly how they looked in 2.0;

Waakul commented 7 months ago

The project cards, Comments, activity layout...

ghost commented 7 months ago

EDIT: Also, this sounds more like "old studio layout addon doesn't make studio pages look almost identical to 2.0"; But that isn't what the addon is supposed to do. Only changes the layout (aka placement). CSS is necessary for that, but the scope of the addon itself doesn't extend to entirely 2.0-'ifying the studio page. EDIT2: Also sorry for the excess edits, but even the addon description says that it's scope is mainly the layout (atleast judging from how it is worded). The way its styled (e.g. comments) is out of scope.

kép

The project cards

You can disagree, but I personally think that's more styling than layout. There's difference on those.

Comments

kép kép

The layout here is unchanged and the same between both old studio layout and 2.0. The styling however, is different.

activity layout

That'd need SA to scrape it from tooltip or make an API request every single time it loads activity.

WorldLanguages commented 7 months ago

Note that studio comments look exactly like project comments, and studio activity looks exactly like the messages page. There's also a "more items per row" addon.

medlans commented 7 months ago

I mean, there is this: https://userstyles.world/style/11602/scratch-3-to-2 Some of the stuff could be modified (such as setting the colors even with theme changes). Though it is not compatible with some Scratch Addons stuff, and I cannot accept studio invites with it on (it automatically adds stuff like stage on the left and bringing back the old location of the green flag)