search

SeleniumHQ / selenium

A browser automation framework and ecosystem.
https://selenium.dev
Apache License 2.0
30.7k stars 8.19k forks source link

Selenium IDE for Firefox does not record values in autoNumeric-managed inputs #3305

Closed AlexandreBonneau closed 7 years ago

AlexandreBonneau commented 7 years ago

System Info

OS: Linux Selenium Version: IDE v2.9.1.1 Browser: Firefox Browser Version: 45.6.0 (64-bit)

Expected Behavior -

Some users have reported that Selenium IDE does not record any inputs when keys are entered into an input managed by autoNumeric.

In the few last comments on this issue https://github.com/BobKnothe/autoNumeric/issues/199, there is a test webpage that shows that bug.

I'm currently running Firefox 45.6.0 and 52.0a2 with Selenium IDE v2.9.1.1, but the bug appears in both version.

Actual Behavior -

Input values are recorded for plain input, but not when those are managed with autoNumeric.

Steps to reproduce -

  1. Go to http://www.antoniob.com/easyedit/userfiles/autonumeric/index.html
  2. Open Selenium IDE
  3. Input some text into the plain input ; Selenium IDE record the values on blur
  4. Input some numbers into the autoNumeric input ; Selenium IDE does not record the values on blur

Since autoNumeric change the input.value on-the-fly, how come Selenium does not pick up any value on blur? The change event is sent correctly too.

barancev commented 7 years ago

Selenium IDE development has been discontinued. No more new features and no bug fixes. From Firefox 55 onwards, Selenium IDE will no longer work [1]. The last supported version is Firefox ESR 52.

Yes, we've started a project to develop a new tool that should replace Selenium IDE. Follow #4406 for the progress.

Sorry this issue has not beed properly and timely addressed, and thank you for submission!

[1] https://seleniumhq.wordpress.com/2017/08/09/firefox-55-and-selenium-ide/

AlexandreBonneau commented 7 years ago

Well, bummer!