cunha
commented
9 months ago Reading the first phrase I was like "why were we thinking on comparing # neighbors vs # of good pairs"? I think these will be correlated for ASes that maintain their RPSL policies well... but this is what seems useful: Trying to relate RPSL policies or operational practices to the observations (# of good pairs).
The second entry in issue #34 goes in this direction: " AS %good pairs vs
RPSL rules". Overall, I think it is worth checking if we can relate
operational practices (in this case the creation of RPSL rules) with route validity (here % of good pairs). Other comparisons might also make sense.
On Sat, Dec 16, 2023 at 7:57 AM Steven Hé (Sīchàng) < @.***> wrote:
In #38 https://github.com/SichangHe/internet_route_verification/issues/38, we planned to plot "AS #neighbors vs #good pairs", but are they correlated?
For convenience, I calculated all correlations: #neighbors, #rules,
import/exports, #report items.
It seems that unfortunately #neighbor is only correlated to #peer. These seem to be correlated.
Column1 Column2 Correlation35 export_meh import_meh 0.87785043 import_err import_meh 0.73908952 export_err import_meh 0.89275553 export_err export_meh 0.92080154 export_err import_err 0.70126758 skip_regex_tilde import_skip 0.99955882 skip_community export_skip 0.85050396 unrec_import_empty import_unrec 0.827590119 unrec_export_empty unrec_import_empty 0.776415160 unrec_route_set import_meh 0.850998161 unrec_route_set export_meh 0.822646163 unrec_route_set export_err 0.908722230 unrec_some_as_set_route unrec_as_set_route 0.992018307 spec_uphill_tier1 import_meh 0.963138308 spec_uphill_tier1 export_meh 0.867745309 spec_uphill_tier1 import_err 0.734378310 spec_uphill_tier1 export_err 0.907111318 spec_uphill_tier1 unrec_route_set 0.837746332 spec_tier1_pair import_meh 0.875641333 spec_tier1_pair export_meh 0.923481334 spec_tier1_pair import_err 0.755159335 spec_tier1_pair export_err 0.976138343 spec_tier1_pair unrec_route_set 0.890857350 spec_tier1_pair spec_uphill_tier1 0.885100405 spec_import_customer_oifps spec_import_peer_oifps 0.998954472 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route import_meh 0.821592473 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route export_meh 0.850151475 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route export_err 0.859303483 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route unrec_route_set 0.810841490 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route spec_uphill_tier1 0.776713491 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route spec_tier1_pair 0.876693628 err_filter_as_set err_filter 0.971174710 err_remote_as_num import_meh 0.881387711 err_remote_as_num export_meh 0.920176712 err_remote_as_num import_err 0.735059713 err_remote_as_num export_err 0.987088721 err_remote_as_num unrec_route_set 0.906280728 err_remote_as_num spec_uphill_tier1 0.897559729 err_remote_as_num spec_tier1_pair 0.996345734 err_remote_as_num spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.867252827 err_peering import_meh 0.881386828 err_peering export_meh 0.920176829 err_peering import_err 0.735059830 err_peering export_err 0.987088838 err_peering unrec_route_set 0.906280845 err_peering spec_uphill_tier1 0.897558846 err_peering spec_tier1_pair 0.996345851 err_peering spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.867252858 err_peering err_remote_as_num 1.0000001377 export import 0.9025571427 neighbor peer 0.9349181482 rules import 0.9775191483 rules export 0.9730511486 import_total import_ok 0.7283201487 import_total export_ok 0.7413941535 import_total customer 0.7549721832 export_total export_ok 0.7717891837 export_total import_meh 0.7590601838 export_total export_meh 0.7131621840 export_total export_err 0.7160811848 export_total unrec_route_set 0.7259711855 export_total spec_uphill_tier1 0.7139911856 export_total spec_tier1_pair 0.7195831861 export_total spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.7032981868 export_total err_remote_as_num 0.7174531871 export_total err_peering 0.7174521880 export_total customer 0.8386201885 export_total import_total 0.9083742213 exchange_total export_ok 0.7729732218 exchange_total import_meh 0.7376062229 exchange_total unrec_route_set 0.7027122261 exchange_total customer 0.8116462266 exchange_total import_total 0.9808952272 exchange_total export_total 0.9723682340 %ok %export_ok 0.9939012409 %skip %export_skip 0.9694162479 %unrec %export_unrec 0.9976242550 %meh %export_meh 0.9907072622 %err %export_err 0.960630— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/SichangHe/internet_route_verification/issues/109, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AACPO53VNLL777M5ZI2RZBLYJV5BTAVCNFSM6AAAAABAXQGXRSVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43ASLTON2WKOZSGA2DINZQGY2TMNQ . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>
SichangHe
In #38, we planned to plot "AS #neighbors vs #good pairs", but are they correlated?
For convenience, I calculated all correlations: #neighbors, #rules, #import/exports, #report items.
It seems that unfortunately #neighbor is only correlated to #peer.
These seem to be correlated.
```ruby Column1 Column2 Correlation 35 export_meh import_meh 0.877850 43 import_err import_meh 0.739089 52 export_err import_meh 0.892755 53 export_err export_meh 0.920801 54 export_err import_err 0.701267 58 skip_regex_tilde import_skip 0.999558 82 skip_community export_skip 0.850503 96 unrec_import_empty import_unrec 0.827590 119 unrec_export_empty unrec_import_empty 0.776415 160 unrec_route_set import_meh 0.850998 161 unrec_route_set export_meh 0.822646 163 unrec_route_set export_err 0.908722 230 unrec_some_as_set_route unrec_as_set_route 0.992018 307 spec_uphill_tier1 import_meh 0.963138 308 spec_uphill_tier1 export_meh 0.867745 309 spec_uphill_tier1 import_err 0.734378 310 spec_uphill_tier1 export_err 0.907111 318 spec_uphill_tier1 unrec_route_set 0.837746 332 spec_tier1_pair import_meh 0.875641 333 spec_tier1_pair export_meh 0.923481 334 spec_tier1_pair import_err 0.755159 335 spec_tier1_pair export_err 0.976138 343 spec_tier1_pair unrec_route_set 0.890857 350 spec_tier1_pair spec_uphill_tier1 0.885100 405 spec_import_customer_oifps spec_import_peer_oifps 0.998954 472 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route import_meh 0.821592 473 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route export_meh 0.850151 475 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route export_err 0.859303 483 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route unrec_route_set 0.810841 490 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route spec_uphill_tier1 0.776713 491 spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route spec_tier1_pair 0.876693 628 err_filter_as_set err_filter 0.971174 710 err_remote_as_num import_meh 0.881387 711 err_remote_as_num export_meh 0.920176 712 err_remote_as_num import_err 0.735059 713 err_remote_as_num export_err 0.987088 721 err_remote_as_num unrec_route_set 0.906280 728 err_remote_as_num spec_uphill_tier1 0.897559 729 err_remote_as_num spec_tier1_pair 0.996345 734 err_remote_as_num spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.867252 827 err_peering import_meh 0.881386 828 err_peering export_meh 0.920176 829 err_peering import_err 0.735059 830 err_peering export_err 0.987088 838 err_peering unrec_route_set 0.906280 845 err_peering spec_uphill_tier1 0.897558 846 err_peering spec_tier1_pair 0.996345 851 err_peering spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.867252 858 err_peering err_remote_as_num 1.000000 1377 export import 0.902557 1427 neighbor peer 0.934918 1482 rules import 0.977519 1483 rules export 0.973051 1486 import_total import_ok 0.728320 1487 import_total export_ok 0.741394 1535 import_total customer 0.754972 1832 export_total export_ok 0.771789 1837 export_total import_meh 0.759060 1838 export_total export_meh 0.713162 1840 export_total export_err 0.716081 1848 export_total unrec_route_set 0.725971 1855 export_total spec_uphill_tier1 0.713991 1856 export_total spec_tier1_pair 0.719583 1861 export_total spec_as_is_origin_but_no_route 0.703298 1868 export_total err_remote_as_num 0.717453 1871 export_total err_peering 0.717452 1880 export_total customer 0.838620 1885 export_total import_total 0.908374 2213 exchange_total export_ok 0.772973 2218 exchange_total import_meh 0.737606 2229 exchange_total unrec_route_set 0.702712 2261 exchange_total customer 0.811646 2266 exchange_total import_total 0.980895 2272 exchange_total export_total 0.972368 2340 %ok %export_ok 0.993901 2409 %skip %export_skip 0.969416 2479 %unrec %export_unrec 0.997624 2550 %meh %export_meh 0.990707 2622 %err %export_err 0.960630 ```